Cottage holiday rentals in Kelleys Island

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Kelleys Island

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favourite

Cottage in Huron

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Cozy Cottage By The Lake, Intimate & Pet Friendly.

Enjoy this newly remodeled & comfortably appointed cozy cottage which features a private fenced in backyard and short walk to view the lake. Conveniently located to easily experience all of your favorite attractions and activities, this stylish and intimate experience might be just what you need! And, we are pet friendly! Visit Cedar Point, Put-in-Bay, Kelley's Island, Kalahari, the Sports Parks, downtown Sandusky, Lake Erie, and nearby nature adventures perfect for hiking and birding. 5-Star!

Superhost

Cottage in Sandusky

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 192 reviews

White waterfront cottage, close to cedar point

Cute waterfront cottage. Completely updated summer 2021 with new flooring throughout, new kitchen, kitchen appliances. New bathroom (2021). Waterfront seating and propane fire pit. Views of Pipe Creek and the east bay of Sandusky Bay. Sleeps 7. Recently added 28’ dock for use (for 2023 season) Close to everything Sandusky and the surrounding areas have to offer. Minutes to Cedar Point, downtown, Sports Force. Check out my guidebooks by clicking on my profile for restaurants and activities!

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Milan

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

Private Hillside Cottage near Cedar Point, Milan

The Odd Cottage is an old house with new tricks. Built in 1853, it stood during the time that Thomas Edison himself wandered the streets of historic Milan, Ohio. Inspired by his story, inside you'll find a modern space that's designed to enable both comfort and creativity. We're centrally located between the area's best attractions: North - Kalahari Resort / 10 min - Sports Force Park / 15 min - Cedar Point / 20 min South - Summit Motorsports Park / 10 min East - Edisons Birthplace / 3 min

Guest favourite

Cottage in Lakeside Marblehead

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 233 reviews

The Boathouse. A Waterfront Retreat on East Harbor

Welcome to Rock Harbor Cottages. "The Boathouse" is an amazing waterfront cottage. The view is second only to the over sized 3+ person jacuzzi tub. Nothing better than waking up and opening your eyes to the amazing view and hearing the water. Close to dining, shopping, beaches, Island ferries, Lakeside, Cedar Point, fishing, and Lake Erie. Perfect couples getaway or to fish Lake Erie. Bring your boat or kayak; boat ramp, dock, and fish cleaning house on property. Private unit. Full kitchen.

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Huron

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 187 reviews

Lake Front Park Cottage - Huron, OH. Lake Erie

Located in the historic Old Plat district this completely updated, high-end home is nestled between Huron’s Lake Front Park or a secluded sandy beach! Park has picnic tables, grills, play-ground, rest rooms. Shortwalk to the Boat Basin & Amphitheater as well as the Huron Lighthouse & Pier. Less than 15 minutes to Cedar Point, Sports Complex, Kalahari, Great Wolf. Near numerous golf courses and everything else that the Lake Erie Islands area has to offer! Minutes to Nickleplate Beach too!

Superhost

Cottage in Lakeside Marblehead

4.7 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Cozy, historic cottage in the center of Lakeside

Our cottage is close to the center of Lakeside, within walking or biking distance to the lakefront and Central Park, Hoover Auditorium, Rhein Arts Center, tennis courts, shops and dining. Nearby places to visit include Cedar Point, Marblehead Lighthouse & Lake Erie Islands. This rustic, 1881 historic cottage is great for couples and families (with kids). New in 2022- back deck, refinished upstairs floors, new flooring in kitchen and bath, on demand hot water heater, washer and dryer.

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Norwalk

5 out of 5 average rating, 95 reviews

Hickory Creek Cottage

Welcome to Hickory Creek Cottage! Our place is designed with couples in mind, to relax & reconnect. Come celebrate a birthday, anniversary, milestone or simply spend quality time together. Enjoy the peaceful setting this property has to offer, while still being close to town and major attractions. Sit back and relax in the hot tub that is open year-round! The outdoor fire pit and indoor fireplace also add to the charm of our cottage. *All guests must be 18 yrs of age to book and/or stay*

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Huron

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 218 reviews

Country Cottage in the woods w/all the Amenities!

Cozy Cottage sleeps 8 Nestled in a wooded setting close to conventions centers, recreation centers, and business headquarters located around northern Ohio. Comfort is our goal for a place to just relax. Spacious comfortable and peaceful describes this charming Country Cottage. This completely updated home is artfully decorated for your complete enjoyment. Features a screened porch, full featured kitchen for preparing meals, washer and dryer. Ample space for multiple car and boat parking.

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Huron

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

Routh@Rye...Huron, OH Cottage with a Lovely View!

Beautiful cottage located on the shore of Lake Erie, next to a private community park. Minutes from Cedar Point, Sports Force Parks, boats headed to Kelleys Island, Put-in-bay, and other fun. Centrally located between Toledo and Cleveland and all the attractions northern Ohio has to offer. Step back in time and enjoy a home large enough for 7-9 people, cozy enough for two, featuring an open living/dining/kitchen; first floor laundry and bath; and three 2nd floor bedrooms and bath.

Superhost

Cottage in Huron

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 205 reviews

Cozy Cottage near CP, Sports Force, & Lake Erie

We are excited to share our cozy, beach-themed cottage with you! We want your stay with us to feel like home away from home, so pack your bags and come to Huron. Fun adventures at the lake await you! We are located only 6 houses from Lake Erie, approx 6 mi from the entrance to Cedar Point, & even less to Sports Force Parks. Our home is ideal for families, couples, or businessmen...at a far better price than any ROOM at a local hotel! If no reviews, we prefer you be 21 to book.

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Oak Harbor

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

Pet Friendly Water Front Private Beach Lake Erie

Bring your fur babies. Let them vacation with you! Amazing views of the water! Truly spectacular! Private beach with lots to do we offer water toys like the Water lily or kayaks, or lay in the sun and play in the sand. You can take a nice long walk or go for a bike ride. We are Walleye capital of the world, so go fishing! Many fishing charters OR you can dock your boat at nearby marina. The house is completely stocked with all the essentials & some non-essentials too.

Guest favourite

Cottage in Port Clinton

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Cozy Lake Cottage 5 min walk to the BEACH

As comfortable as it is beautiful, our renovated lake house is ready for you to enjoy all that the Port Clinton area has to offer. Spend the day at the beach, island hopping via the Jett Express, wine tasting in Catawba or adrenaline seeking at Cedar Point. Come home and cook in our fully equipped kitchen or throw your catch of the day on the grill and enjoy the backyard. Not into cooking? We're just a mile from the downtown restaurants and bars! Smart TV, Wifi, beds for 6.