Holiday rentals in Forestburg Pond

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Forestburg Pond

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favourite

A stylish kitchen area features dark cabinetry and a large island with seating. The ceiling is adorned with decorative wallpaper, while modern lighting fixtures create a warm atmosphere. A black refrigerator and oven are visible, along with various kitchenware displayed on open shelves.

Home in Eldred

Hot tub, fire pit, and quirky design

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. A designer renovated 1920s cottage in the Catskills on a windy road near the Delaware River. Hideaway 2 hours from NYC and short drive to restaurants and retail in Barryville, Narrowsburg & Callicoon. This cottage hosts 2 bedrooms, open living, dining and kitchen, a bathroom with a rain shower and a mudroom with laundry. The larger bedroom features a workspace. The yard is now fully fenced, has a BBQ grill, fire pit, outdoor dining and hot tub.

LocationFamilyDecor

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Guest favourite

A cozy gray house is surrounded by greenery, featuring a welcoming entrance with a flower pot by the steps. A pathway made of flat stones leads to the front door, while large windows allow natural light to fill the interior.

Home in Forestburgh

Cozy Creek House

Reconnect with nature at this cozy, tranquil, wilderness escape. This charming three bedroom home set off a quiet country road, situated among the dense woods and a picturesque meadow has a babbling creek running through the property. Walking distance to quaint Forestburgh General Store & funky Forage Pizza. Only a short drive from local Playhouse, distilleries, wineries, antique shops, Rio Reservoir, lakes, rivers, springs, waterfalls, and hiking trails in thousands of acres of state forest.

LocationFamilyOutdoor spaces

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 79 reviews

Top guest favourite

A serene outdoor seating area features two wooden chairs positioned beside a stone platform. A fire pit with a crackling flame is set in front of the chairs, overlooking a gently flowing creek and lush greenery, creating a tranquil nature retreat.

Cabin in Millrift

Remote Waterfall Cabin at Swiftwater Acres

Deep in a lush oak forest, on the bank of Bushkill Creek sits this hidden oasis. This is simply THEE most private abode in the entire area. Situated just feet from the water, the falls can be seen and heard from every room within the cabin’s charming, rustic interior. This spectacular 45 acre parcel is set within a vast reserve of state land: an oasis within an oasis. Just 90 minutes from NYC, this is a truly sublime atmosphere, perfect for those seeking a rejuvenating and inspiring getaway.

FamilyValueGrill

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 294 reviews

Top guest favourite

Cabin in Yulan

Enchanting River A-Frame|Fire Pit| Magical Forest

Escape to our Magical Riverside A-Frame on 4 secluded acres. Swim in the enchanting river, grill dinner under the trees, and gather by the fire pit beneath twinkling string lights & a sky scattered with endless stars. Watch deer, eagles & fireflies as you unwind in this cozy 2BR cabin. Perfect for couples, nature lovers, and anyone craving a peaceful retreat. Minutes from scenic hikes & Delaware River adventures connecting deep with nature - leave feeling like you stepped out of a storybook.

ValueLocationCleanliness

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 243 reviews

Top guest favourite

A castle-style retreat is showcased, featuring a whimsical dragon statue and a large chess set in the foreground. A tranquil pond with a fountain is visible, alongside a magnificent castle structure designed with classic stone elements and a welcoming entrance, all set amidst lush greenery.

Castle in East Stroudsburg

Pocono Castle: Dungeon Escape Room & Private Pond

Sleep in a Fairy Tale at Pocono Castle! Live the dream in this 2,300 sq. ft storybook retreat, where you’ll sleep like royalty in a real fairy tale castle. Unwind in luxury with a bubbling hot tub, a cedar sauna, and endless magical touches. Dress up as Kings, Queens, or Knights and explore the grounds, featuring a private one-acre pond & maybe you’ll catch a Golden Fish! With enchanting bedrooms, outdoor adventures, and unforgettable charm, this is the OMG getaway you’ve been waiting for!

ValueFamilyWifi

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 481 reviews

Top guest favourite

The living room features a spacious couch, modern lighting, and a wood-burning fireplace, with a flat-screen TV mounted above a decorative white wall. Large windows invite natural light, while sliding glass doors open to the deck. A minimalist chair adds an additional seating option.

Cottage in Monticello

Modern Upstate Escape with Outdoor Sauna

Recently renovated two bedroom, two bath cottage with four person barrel sauna at Swinging Bridge Reservoir, Sullivan County's largest motorboat lake. Updated amenities and mid-century and modern furniture provide a welcome respite from the city just 90 miles away. Take in the local scenery, catch a show at the Forestburgh Playhouse or stop into some of the local vineyards and restaurants. For a low key weekend, hang out by the fireplace playing some records and cooking a meal.

ValueFamilyAmenities

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 416 reviews

Guest favourite

Cabin in Wurtsboro

Forest Spa Retreat on Cascading Brook • 90 Min NYC

Tucked into an evergreen forest, The Water House is a private spa retreat set above a cascading brook—where flowing water shapes your stay. Spend slow mornings on the deck, unwind in the hot tub, and gather by the fire pit under the stars. Find a quiet moment beside the Japanese-inspired pond. Inside, soft textures and vintage style create a warm, calming atmosphere designed to reconnect you with nature while offering the restful comfort of a boutique retreat.

LocationValueHospitality

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 461 reviews

Guest favourite

Cabin in Forestburgh

Spirit Cabin - Lakefront with Pool, Sauna & Cold P

Escape to this elegant 3-bed, 3-bath modern lakefront cabin in Forestburgh—just 2 hrs from NYC. Discover this breathtaking home set on 5 lakefront acres. Immerse yourself in limitless enjoyment with amenities both indoors and out. Enjoy the heated pool, hot tub, sauna, *new cold plunge, and firepit. Experience water sports on the lake with provided equipment. Perfect for relaxation and adventure! Explore Nearby towns of Livingston Manor and Narrowsburg.

LocationValueBathroom

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 76 reviews

Top guest favourite

A modern house with a large glass wall is nestled among tall trees beside a serene waterway. A spacious deck extends from the home, offering a view of the surroundings. The landscape features a gently sloping yard leading to the water's edge.

Home in Monticello

Secluded lakefront home With an EV charger

Welcome to your oasis on the Swiniging Bridge Reservoir! Only 90 minutes from NYC, but a world away. A complete glass wall facing the water allows guests to take in the views and sounds of a babbling brook that feeds into a motorboat lake. This brand new house sleeps 6 adults (or 4 adults and 3 children) and features a full kitchen, free WiFi, bedding, linens, and toiletries. A canoe and paddleboat are also available for your use!

LocationValueAccuracy

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 186 reviews

Guest favourite

Home in Monticello

Luxury Lakefront Estate | Private Beach & Spa

✓ Lakefront home w/ sandy beach ✓ Covered hot tub ✓ Massive deck w/ outdoor kitchen + BBQ ✓ Private dock ✓ HDTV 55” w/ Netflix, Hulu, Prime ✓ 336 Mbps wifi ✓ Driveway for 6 cars + land across the street for 6 more ★”The view and the lake access was just what we wanted” 3 min→ Swinging bridge marina 20 min→ Resort Worlds Casino @thestarlightny

ValueLocationAccuracy

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 195 reviews

Top guest favourite

The living area features large windows that allow natural light to fill the space, complemented by a wood-burning stove. A cozy gray sofa and rustic chairs surround a circular wooden coffee table, while a textured area rug adds warmth to the hardwood floor.

Home in Monticello

Dancing Feather: Cozy Lake-Front A-Frame Chalet

Sunlight pours into every room at this delightful lake front A-frame cabin. Enjoy a cozy fireside dinner with friends or an evening under the stars with warm blankets provided. Appreciate the quiet and tranquility that is found here on the lake. Create unforgettable memories at this peaceful lake front home.

FamilyValueAccuracy

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 272 reviews

Top guest favourite

A tranquil scene featuring cascading waterfalls flowing over stone ledges into a clear pool. Lush greenery surrounds the water, while a stone patio and a single chair are visible nearby, providing a serene spot for relaxation among nature.

Cottage in Matamoras

The Cottage at Bluestone Falls

We call this The Cottage. It is one of three guest houses on 16 park-like acres, nestled into the woods, running along the scenic Bushkill Creek in the NE tip of the Poconos, near the Delaware River. All 3 houses are set quite far apart on the property and offer the perfect amount of privacy.

FamilyLocationIndoor spaces

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 199 reviews