Holiday rentals in Fairy Island

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Fairy Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favourite

A wooden dock extends toward a calm lake, featuring a covered boat and a sunbathing area with a chair. A yellow floating mat lies nearby, and the water reflects the surrounding greenery. Swimmers can be seen enjoying the gentle waves in the distance.

Home in Mukwonago

Lake House Retreat on Phantom Lake

A cozy secluded retreat like being "up North" without having to go up North. Quiet private road, and quiet lake. Great swimming and fishing off the dock in this sandy bottom lake with clean spring fed water, and large grassy area for lawn games and relaxing. Great for families, ladies retreats, golf groups, or concert goers. Only 5 mins to grocery stores. Lots of space in the house, and lots of space for spending time outside on the deck or the dock or lawn by the lake. Feel free to inquire!

FamilyLocationBack garden

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Guest favourite

A cozy cabin overlooks a tranquil lake, surrounded by lush greenery. A wooden deck leads to an inviting seating area with several white chairs arranged in a semi-circle around a campfire pit. Large windows with red trim add character to the structure.

Guest house in Elkhorn

Camp Wandawega: Lakeside 3 Bedroom Cabin

Overlooking the lake nestled right behind the main lodge, this cabin has 3 bedrooms, a half bathroom, a seating a room, a basic kitchenette & access to camp showers downstairs. One large bedroom has a queen bed, one room with bunkbeds, & one with a full bed to accommodate a max of 6 guests. (But the bunkbeds are best for kid-sized humans). Like all of Wandawega, it’s a back-to-basics, no-frills, primitive experience. Simple rooms, vintage furnishings. There is heat & a couple AC window units.

FamilyValueBathroom

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 183 reviews

Guest favourite

An expansive wooden deck offers a welcoming outdoor space, featuring a dining table surrounded by chairs and a cozy rattan chair. A large umbrella stands in one corner, while lush greenery and blue skies create a serene backdrop.

Cabin in Elkhorn

The Retreat: 5 Acre Log Cabin

Escape to this beautiful 5-acre country retreat, located a short drive from Lauderdale Lakes, Alpine Valley, and Lake Geneva. The cabin features two kitchens, two family rooms, a year around outdoor hot tub, a game room, and five bedrooms with comfortable king-sized beds. The master suite also includes a steam room for added luxury. Spend your days enjoying the great outdoors with a game of beach volleyball or roasting marshmallows around a bonfire, while taking in the fresh midwestern air.

LocationFamilyAccuracy

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 332 reviews

Guest favourite

Place to stay in Racine

Wisconsin Treehouse Getaway!

Featured in Timeout Magazine as Chicago's Top 10 Airbnbs, and in other outlets as Wisconsin's most romantic and top 5 Airbnbs, this space has an immersive nature experience, overlooking a creek and woods with all modern comforts. Imagine yourself in a cabin in the woods to unplug and recharge, waking up to chirping birds as if in a Treehouse! 3 miles to Lake Michigan & dwntn. lf we're home, a complimentary Chai! Come, make lifelong memories at Racine's Best Kept Secret No local bookings.

FamilyValueBiking

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 828 reviews

Top guest favourite

Cottage in Burlington

The Butterfly Cottage

Your summer get-away is perfect at The Butterfly Cottage on Honey Lake! Relax and enjoy the serenity of the lake and all the natural beauty of the season! This is a cozy cottage on Honey Lake, just 4 miles from downtown Burlington and 13 miles from Lake Geneva. Alpine Valley for concerts and skiing, fishing on Honey Lake or nearby Browns Lake as well as shopping in Lake Geneva are the highlights of the area! There are hiking/walking trails all around as well as rustic roads to explore.

FamilyLocationKitchen

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Top guest favourite

Home in Elkhorn

Private House on 5 acres - Walk to Alpine Valley

Valley Oasis is a private 3 bedroom 2 bath home located on 5 acres next to the entrance of Alpine Valley Resort. Far enough off the road to enjoy the quiet beauty of nature. Woods located behind the house and a field next to it. Enjoy the outdoors on the deck, have dinner in the screened in porch, enjoy a fire in the fire pit, or warm up by the fireplace. You will have access to the entire house and immediate yard. The garage is not accessible. No smoking in the home. No parties allowed.

LocationFamilyHospitality

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 40 reviews

Top guest favourite

A large window frames a tranquil view of the lake, allowing natural light to brighten the space. The colorful wall adds a vibrant backdrop, while a cozy seating area invites relaxation. A circular table is positioned nearby, complementing the inviting atmosphere.

Home in Waterford

Wow! Beautiful Lake Cottage Pontoon Boat&Fire Pit

Welcome to our newly renovated cottage with a breathtaking view! As you walk into our house, you'll immediately be taken away by the stunning vista and how close we are to the lake. The decor is meticulously designed, and we have plenty of seating for up to a family of six. With three bedrooms and two baths, you can enjoy your vacation or getaway in utmost comfort and peace. Get ready to unwind, relax, and be captivated by the beauty of the lake. Come and experience it for yourself!

FamilyValueNearby

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 69 reviews

Guest favourite

The striking A-frame exterior features large triangular windows that allow natural light to flood the interior. The patio area includes seating for relaxation and a hot tub, set against a backdrop of lush surrounding trees, enhancing the connection with nature.

Cabin in Bloomfield

Modern A-Frame Lake Cabin w/ Pickleball Ct.4Bd 3Ba

Escape to this stunning A-frame home in Genoa City, Wisconsin, where tranquility meets adventure. Just minutes away from Nippersink golf course, Lake Geneva and Wilmot Ski Resort. Nearby Cabin offers a range of amenities designed to enhance your stay. Including a private pickleball court, hot tub, kayaks, and many more. Providing private lake access, and a private pier, this spacious vacation rental is the perfect getaway for families and groups looking to unwind and explore.

LocationValueHospitality

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 88 reviews

Top guest favourite

The cottage features a charming facade with a combination of blue siding and stonework. Two sets of double doors are framed by large windows, allowing natural light to fill the entrance. Flower beds line the pathway leading to the front door, enhancing the welcoming appearance.

Home in Elkhorn

Cozy Country Cottage near Lake Geneva, WI

Our Cozy Cottage features 3 comfortable bedrooms and nightly magnificent sunsets. Nestled on a country road, the house offers plenty of space to rest after visiting Lake Geneva, Lauderdale lakes, biking at Kettle Moraine or site seeing in the area. It’s close to Walworth County fair grounds where the flea market, Das Fest and Rib Fest are held. This is country living with plenty of opportunity to enjoy the beautiful outdoors or the peace and quiet of the countryside.

ValueLocationWifi

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Top guest favourite

The exterior of the classic A-frame cabin, featuring a striking red facade, is set against a backdrop of lush greenery. A wooden walkway leads to a seating area with two chairs. A deck is visible, providing an inviting space to relax outdoors.

Home in Palmyra

A-Frame in forest on bike trail!

Classic A-Frame, in the woods. Borders the Kettle Moraine State Forest on 3 sides. Exterior: 2 acres, fully-fenced and dog-friendly. Hop on the "Connector" mountain bike trail right out the backyard. Or take a hike on the nearby Ice Age trail, Bald Bluff, John Muir, Nordic, or snowmobile trails. Interior: 1,500 square feet, 2 levels, open concept main living area with loft ceiling, wood-burning fireplace, 2 arcade machines, outdoor firepit, frisbee golf stand, etc.

FamilyLocationDecor

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Guest favourite

The A-frame cabin is set amidst tall trees at dusk, featuring a spacious deck with railing and soft lighting. The vibrant red exterior contrasts with the natural surroundings, while large windows highlight the interior ambiance. A gravel path leads up to the entrance.

Cabin in Lake Geneva

A-Frame Retreat w/ Hot Tub, Sauna & Cold Plunge

Tucked in the woods near Lake Geneva, The Cozy Cardinal is a dreamy A-frame retreat with a hot tub, panoramic sauna, cold plunge, fire pit, and private forest trail. Watch birds and wildlife from the deck—this is a Certified Wildlife Habitat! Cozy up by the fireplace, sway in hammock swings, or enjoy s’mores under the stars. Dog-friendly and sleeps 4. Just minutes from downtown, hiking, and the lake—yet it feels a world away. Perfect for fall color and snowy escapes.

ValueFamilyCleanliness

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 84 reviews

Guest favourite

Home in East Troy

Historic 1868 Farmhouse Kettle Moraine Getaway

Escape to an elegantly restored 1868 Italianate manor on 4.5 private acres. Once home to the Johnston Cookie family, this farm blends old-world charm with modern luxury. Whether it’s a family reunion or a romantic retreat, enjoy high tin ceilings, a designer chef’s kitchen, and a master suite with a clawfoot tub. Located in the heart of Kettle Moraine hiking, skiing, and concerts are just minutes away. Relax, unplug, and rejuvenate.

LocationIndoor spacesTV

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews