Some info has been automatically translated. Show original language

Holiday rentals in Bay Shore

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Quick stats about holiday rentals in Bay Shore

  • Total holiday rentals

    Explore 50 holiday rentals in Bay Shore

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Bay Shore holiday rentals start at €44 per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 2,380 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Family-friendly holiday rentals

    10 properties offer extra space & child-friendly amenities

  • Pet-friendly holiday rentals

    Find 10 rentals that welcome pets

  • Rentals with dedicated workspaces

    30 properties have a dedicated workspace

  • Wifi availability

    50 of Bay Shore holiday rentals include wifi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi and Pool across Bay Shore rentals

  • 4.8 Average rating

    Bay Shore stays are highly rated by guests – averaging 4.8 out of 5!

Top-rated holiday rentals in Bay Shore

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favourite
Flat in Bay Shore
5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Charming Studio Close to Everything!

Welcome to this cozy studio just a few minutes from the beach, dining, shopping, Fire Island ferries and local hospitals. Perfect for solo travelers or couples, the space includes a private entrance, comfy queen bed, kitchenette(no stove or burners), microwave, small fridge, coffeemaker, clean private bathroom, WiFi, and free parking. Enjoy a peaceful stay in a convenient location close to everything you need. Whether you're here to explore, work, or relax, this studio is the perfect home base.

Guest favourite
Flat in Bay Shore
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 132 reviews

♡Cozy 1Br Apt,Garden Patio & Off Street Parking♡

Welcome to Bay Shore! Renovated, private 1 Bedroom Apartment with new windows, hardwood floors & a full kitchen. - Designated guest parking in driveway - First floor Apt., no stairs. Just step up from patio right into Apt. - Queen Size Bed - Living Room with Sofa bed for a 3rd guest - Smart TV - Fast 1024 Mpbs WIFI - Large Hallway Walk in Closet for luggage, etc. 2 Miles -Downtown Bayshore for Restaurants etc. 7 mins -SouthShore University Hospital 15 mins - Robert Moses State Park

Guest favourite
Flat in Bay Shore
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 330 reviews

Amazing Fully Furnished near Fire Island Ferries

*Alternative to High Priced Fire Island yet minutes away! *Amazing Fully Furnished Ground level apartment with Office, Private Front Entrance and Private Deck *Daily, Weekly, Monthly. Seasonal rates "Hotel Style Setting- Turn-key Apartment *Centrally located within all major roadways on Long Island *Close to Westfield Mall and Downtown Main Street with many restaurants and bars. ****Great spot for those who got kicked out by wifey/hubby NO PARTIES PHOTO SHOOTS!!!

Top guest favourite
A comfortable living area features a light-colored sofa facing a wall-mounted television. A small dining table with two chairs is positioned nearby. Natural light enters through a door leading to an exterior space, and wooden flooring complements the overall layout.
Flat in Central Islip
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 164 reviews

Cozy studio w/ private entrance

Perfect for solo travelers or couples.This new, cozy studio is part of a larger home but fully self-contained w/ its own entrance. Inside, you’ll find: - A comfy living area with a pull-out twin bed and seating - A kitchen with essentials for light cooking - A private bathroom with shower, towels, and toiletries - High-speed Wi-Fi and a flat-screen TV Though attached to our home, your space is private. Located in a quiet neighborhood, close to attractions, restaurants, and transportation.

Top guest favourite
Guest house in Islip Terrace
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

The Sunshine House

Enjoy your stay and visit the Bayard Cutting Arboretum, SUSA Orlin & Cohen Sports Complex, Robert Moses Beach; centrally located between The Hamptons Vineyard Wine Tours & Manhattan. This unique home was originally built in 1921 and has since undergone renovations with additions added to the original structure, including the three bedroom / bath guest wing with a private entrance from the main house. We provide beverages and continental breakfast. Please email us for more details!

Top guest favourite
A modern living area features a blue sofa adorned with yellow accent pillows and a cozy throw pillow. A wooden coffee table sits in front, topped with decorative items. Light-colored walls are complemented by floral artwork, creating a welcoming and relaxed atmosphere.
Flat in West Babylon
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 283 reviews

Loft 36 | King Sized Spacious Apartment

Welcome to Loft 36. A modern *private upstairs apartment* in a safe residential Long Island Neighborhood. Spacious and fully furnished with a private keyless entrance. Centrally located in the heart of WEST BABYLON. We are a quick trip to Babylon Village shops, bars, and restaurants, Tanger Outlets, Jones Beach, Robert Moses, and Marina Beaches. Ferries to Fire Island also close by. About an hour drive to New York City via nearby expressway or a 65 minute railroad ride.

Guest favourite
A cozy living area features a small dining table set for two, a comfortable cream-colored sofa adorned with decorative pillows, and a matching ottoman. A workspace with a desk and chair is positioned nearby. Light curtains frame the window, and greenery adds a refreshing touch.
Home in Islip
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Sundown Escape Near SouthShore University Hospital

Cozy, modern space perfect for relaxing or working remotely. Features a comfy armchair, small workspace, dining table for two, and a coffee bar. Bedroom includes a queen bed with LED lighting, TV, mirror, bench, ALEXA, and closet with storage. Bathroom has a walk-in shower, complementary shampoo, conditioner, and body wash. Close to hospitals, colleges, shops, and main roads.

Top guest favourite
A vibrant sunset fills the sky with shades of pink, purple, and orange over the calm waterfront. Silhouettes of trees and nearby boats create a serene backdrop against the colorful horizon, complementing the tranquil scene by the dock.
Home in Bay Shore
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 79 reviews

Bay Shore Boat House

Waterfront retreat with stunning views, a designer kitchen, serene interiors, and outdoor amenities including a fire pit, bluestone raised patio, and cabana bar. Ideal for couples and families. Walking distance to downtown Bay Shore, close to Fire Island Ferries and Captain Bill's. Unwind, fish off the dock, and witness unforgettable sunsets. Your perfect escape awaits.

Superhost
Flat in Central Islip
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Cozy apartment with private entrance

Cozy apartment for single or couple in the heart of Long Island. This new listing is located on the first floor of a 2 story house with its own entrance. As you walking you are greeted with a nice living room with a pull sofa, a dining table a well equipped kitchen and a nice size bathroom. The bedroom has a queen size with comfortable bed set for a wonderful night.

Guest favourite
Guest suite in Bay Shore
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Peaceful living Bayshore- Walk to Ferry & LIRR

Private 1-bedroom guest suite with full kitchen, cozy living area, and modern bathroom. Just 2 blocks from the LIRR, 5 minutes to dining & shops, and 10 minutes to the Fire Island Ferry. Wi-Fi, smart TV, laundry & all utilities included. No yard access. 1 pet is allowed for a one time $80 fee. Early checkin and late checkout is available for a small fee.

Guest favourite
A spacious bedroom is presented with two beds side by side, surrounded by built-in bookshelves filled with books. Natural light filters through sheer curtains, illuminating the cozy nook with a window seat. A television is positioned in the corner, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
Flat in Bay Shore
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Stay downtown & walk to Fire Island ferries

Spacious, private, ground floor space located in a mid-19th Century Mansard Victorian in Historic Bay District of downtown Bay Shore. Steps to dozens of restaurants, a spray park, beach, and ferry. 10 minute walk from LIRR. Child friendly. Please note that host’s family lives in the main house. Ask us about special add-ons to enhance your stay!

Superhost
Flat in Bay Shore
4.59 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Cozy Stay w/ Bedroom, Kitchen, and Deck

A cozy and well-organized space with a private bedroom, a comfortable sitting area, a full kitchen, and a clean bathroom. Step outside onto the deck to enjoy fresh air and quiet moments, whether you’re starting your morning or winding down in the evening. Designed for convenience and ease, it’s a comfortable and place to relax after a day out.

Popular amenities for Bay Shore holiday rentals

When is the best time to visit Bay Shore?

MonthJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDec
Avg. price€105€106€110€103€113€113€151€155€114€114€113€109
Avg. temp0°C1°C4°C10°C15°C21°C24°C23°C19°C13°C8°C3°C

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are the best places to stay in Bay Shore?

    Many guests choose stays near the marina, in residential neighborhoods, or close to Main Street for convenient access to shops, dining, and the waterfront. Options range from private homes to apartments and cozy cottages.

  • What are the best things to do in Bay Shore with kids?

    Families often explore playgrounds, catch live performances at local theaters, or visit nature centers in and around Bay Shore. Seasonal events frequently feature activities designed for children.

  • What are some of the best things to do in Bay Shore?

    Explore the marina, browse local shops and restaurants along Main Street, or catch a ferry to Fire Island. Parks and seasonal markets around Bay Shore add to the experience for visitors of all ages.

  • How is the weather in Bay Shore?

    Bay Shore experiences cold winters, around 25–39°F (-4–4°C), and warm summers, near 67–83°F (20–28°C). Spring and fall have milder temperatures and comfortable conditions for outdoor activities.

  • When is the best time to visit Bay Shore?

    Late spring through early fall is often recommended for warmer weather and lively waterfront events. Visitors seeking quieter moments might prefer the milder days of early fall or spring.

  • What are the best places to visit in Bay Shore?

    Explore the marina area, wander along Main Street’s shops and eateries, and take a ferry toward Fire Island. Neighborhood parks and local galleries provide additional ways to experience Bay Shore’s energy.

  • What are some hiking trails in Bay Shore?

    Bay Shore has walking paths through community parks and nearby nature preserves, with opportunities to spot local wildlife. Trails on Fire Island are also frequently suggested for those interested in a coastal hike.

  • What are some family activities we can do in Bay Shore?

    Families can explore parks, take part in beach activities, or visit local museums and nature centers. Community events and farmers markets often have interactive spaces for kids.

  • What are some of the best day trip ideas from Bay Shore?

    Consider exploring Fire Island’s beaches, visiting nearby vineyards, or strolling through botanical gardens around Long Island. Art museums and historic estates are also frequently suggested for a day’s outing.

  • Are there any pet friendly accommodations available in Bay Shore?

    Pet friendly accommodations can be found throughout Bay Shore, particularly near parks and green spaces. Hosts may provide amenities such as fenced yards or easy access to walking trails for visitors traveling with pets.

  • What are some local tips for visiting Bay Shore?

    Wear comfortable shoes for exploring downtown and the waterfront, and consider booking ahead for dining or ferry trips. Checking seasonal event calendars can help you experience local traditions and gatherings.

  • What is Bay Shore known for?

    Bay Shore has a lively waterfront, historic downtown streets, and access to Fire Island beaches. The area is frequently suggested for its maritime character and community events throughout the year.

  • What are the best hidden gems to explore in Bay Shore?

    Bay Shore has tucked-away parks, small art galleries, and cozy local coffee spots. Nature trails and lesser-known gardens around the area invite peaceful moments away from busier streets.

  • What are the best foods to try in Bay Shore?

    Bay Shore’s restaurants are known for fresh seafood dishes, traditional Italian cuisine, and classic American fare. Locally made bagels and bakery treats are also frequently suggested.

  • What should I bring for a trip to Bay Shore?

    Pack layers, a light jacket, and comfortable walking shoes, as weather can change between seasons. A swimsuit and sun protection are helpful for beach or outdoor activities during warmer months.

  • What is the nightlife in Bay Shore like?

    Bay Shore has a mix of welcoming pubs, cocktail lounges, and venues where you can listen to live music. The nightlife scene is relaxed, with opportunities for late-evening dining and social gatherings.

  • What are the most popular events or festivals in Bay Shore?

    Community street fairs, live music events in the summer, and holiday parades are among the most popular gatherings in Bay Shore. Food festivals and art shows also take place throughout the year, drawing neighbors and visitors alike.

  • Are there family friendly vacation rentals in Bay Shore?

    Bay Shore has family friendly rentals near the waterfront, local parks, and residential neighborhoods. Many hosts include features like kitchens, multiple bedrooms, or outdoor spaces to help families feel at home.

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Suffolk County
  5. Bay Shore