Best cheesecakes in New York

Check out the top cheesecakes in New York, reviewed and ranked by the city’s locals
1. Make My Cake
1. Make My Cake
host-0host-1host-2
11 local reviews
121 Saint Nicholas Avenue, New York
Open now
+1 212-932-0833
BakeryFoodStore
Julian
One of the sweetest landmarks of Harlem is Make My Cake. There are two locations -- one on St. Nicholas Ave an…
Toyin
Specialty cakes, cheesecakes, cupcakes & pies
Jorin
One of NYC's great old Jazz Clubs. This is there the famous photo "A Great Day in Harlem" was taken.
1. Make My Cake
1. Make My Cake
host-0host-1host-2
11 local reviews
121 Saint Nicholas Avenue, New York
Open now
+1 212-932-0833
Julian
Julian
One of the sweetest landmarks of Harlem is Make My Cake. There are two locations -- one on St. Nicholas Ave and one on Adam C. Powell Blvd. …
Toyin
Toyin
Specialty cakes, cheesecakes, cupcakes & pies
Jorin
Jorin
One of NYC's great old Jazz Clubs. This is there the famous photo "A Great Day in Harlem" was taken.
2. Eileen's Special Cheesecake
2. Eileen's Special Cheesecake
host-0host-1host-2
6 local reviews
17 Cleveland Place, New York
Open now
+1 212-966-5585
BakeryRestaurantFood
Carol
The house special is still fluffy after all these years, and the kitchen keeps a dizzying array of varieties t…
A.K.
Best cheesecake in NYC. Get the salted caramel creme brulee cheesecake! Closes at 9pm.
Frederick
Unbelievably good and famous cheesecakes!
2. Eileen's Special Cheesecake
2. Eileen's Special Cheesecake
host-0host-1host-2
6 local reviews
17 Cleveland Place, New York
Open now
+1 212-966-5585
Carol
Carol
The house special is still fluffy after all these years, and the kitchen keeps a dizzying array of varieties that encompass trendiness (salt…
A.K.
A.K.
Best cheesecake in NYC. Get the salted caramel creme brulee cheesecake! Closes at 9pm.
Frederick
Frederick
Unbelievably good and famous cheesecakes!
3. Junior's Restaurant & Bakery
3. Junior's Restaurant & Bakery
host-0host-1host-2
14 local reviews
386 Flatbush Avenue Extension
Open now
+1 718-852-5257
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Antonia
If you are a lover of great cheesecake, historical Junior's cheesecake is the place you ought to visit during …
Noreen (& Bax)
Stop for lunch or just swing by and bring home some of the famous cheesecake to snack on later. I still don't …
Deborah
Historic Landmark and restaurant with legendary cheesecake! Try the Strawberry and a Hot Pastrami sandwich!
3. Junior's Restaurant & Bakery
3. Junior's Restaurant & Bakery
host-0host-1host-2
14 local reviews
386 Flatbush Avenue Extension
Open now
+1 718-852-5257
Antonia
Antonia
If you are a lover of great cheesecake, historical Junior's cheesecake is the place you ought to visit during your stay in NYC. You will no…
Noreen (& Bax)
Noreen (& Bax)
Stop for lunch or just swing by and bring home some of the famous cheesecake to snack on later. I still don't know if the day I learned they…
Deborah
Deborah
Historic Landmark and restaurant with legendary cheesecake! Try the Strawberry and a Hot Pastrami sandwich!
4. Veniero's Pastry
4. Veniero's Pastry
host-0host-1host-2
18 local reviews
342 East 11th Street, New York
Open now
+1 212-674-7070
BakeryCafeFood
Bianca
Once upon a time I used to work here and I loved it so much I still go back on the regular. It's an Italian ba…
Helen
This is a classic traditional italian Pastry that has been here for a century. The have amazing pastries and …
Brooke & Terry
Possibly the best Italian pastries in NYC. Try their cheesecake - it is outstanding.
4. Veniero's Pastry
4. Veniero's Pastry
host-0host-1host-2
18 local reviews
342 East 11th Street, New York
Open now
+1 212-674-7070
Bianca
Bianca
Once upon a time I used to work here and I loved it so much I still go back on the regular. It's an Italian bakery that has been open for 11…
Helen
Helen
This is a classic traditional italian Pastry that has been here for a century. The have amazing pastries and a huge selection of cheesecake…
Brooke & Terry
Brooke & Terry
Possibly the best Italian pastries in NYC. Try their cheesecake - it is outstanding.
5. Junior's Cheesecake
5. Junior's Cheesecake
host-0host-1host-2
10 local reviews
386 Flatbush Ave Ext
Open now
(718) 852-5257
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Marie
It's one of NYC's most known restaurants because of its cheesecake :)
C.S.
Junior's Cheesecake is famous for a reason. It's simply delicious. You'll never have another slice of cheese…
Andre
Iconic original Brooklyn-made cheesecake - this is a must if you've never had it before
5. Junior's Cheesecake
5. Junior's Cheesecake
host-0host-1host-2
10 local reviews
386 Flatbush Ave Ext
Open now
(718) 852-5257
Marie
Marie
It's one of NYC's most known restaurants because of its cheesecake :)
C.S.
C.S.
Junior's Cheesecake is famous for a reason. It's simply delicious. You'll never have another slice of cheesecake that beats it. Its extrem…
Andre
Andre
Iconic original Brooklyn-made cheesecake - this is a must if you've never had it before
6. Junior's Restaurant
6. Junior's Restaurant
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
1515 Broadway, New York
Open now
(212) 302-2000
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Jose
P Diddy likes this place, they actually make a mean cheesecake.
The
One of the best cheesecakes in NYC!
Andreacarola
Cheesecake bakery
6. Junior's Restaurant
6. Junior's Restaurant
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
1515 Broadway, New York
Open now
(212) 302-2000
Jose
Jose
P Diddy likes this place, they actually make a mean cheesecake.
The
The
One of the best cheesecakes in NYC!
Andreacarola
Andreacarola
Cheesecake bakery