Best American restaurants in New York

Check out the top American restaurants in New York, reviewed and ranked by the city’s locals
1. The Red Cat
1. The Red Cat
host-0host-1
0 local reviews
227 10th Ave, Manhattan
Open · Closes 10:00 PM
+1 212-242-1122
BarRestaurantPoint of interest
Sergio
Great American restaurant
Rose
4 stars American restaurant
1. The Red Cat
1. The Red Cat
host-0host-1
0 local reviews
227 10th Ave, Manhattan
Open · Closes 10:00 PM
+1 212-242-1122
Sergio
Sergio
Great American restaurant
Rose
Rose
4 stars American restaurant
2. Peaches
2. Peaches
host-0host-1host-2
0 local reviews
393 Lewis Ave, Brooklyn
Open · Closes 4:00 PM
+1 718-942-4162
RestaurantPoint of interestFood
Laura
American Restaurant, Southern comfort food and they serve lunch, brunch and dinner. I have heard that the foo…
Isabel
Peaches is a Classic American Restaurant with a nod to the South. Open for lunch and dinner.
Garnet
Good Food. “Peaches is a Classic American Restaurant with a nod to the South. Nestled in Stuyvesant ..."
2. Peaches
2. Peaches
host-0host-1host-2
0 local reviews
393 Lewis Ave, Brooklyn
Open · Closes 4:00 PM
+1 718-942-4162
Laura
Laura
American Restaurant, Southern comfort food and they serve lunch, brunch and dinner. I have heard that the food here is really good, but hav…
Isabel
Isabel
Peaches is a Classic American Restaurant with a nod to the South. Open for lunch and dinner.
Garnet
Garnet
Good Food. “Peaches is a Classic American Restaurant with a nod to the South. Nestled in Stuyvesant ..."
3. Hearth
3. Hearth
host-0host-1
0 local reviews
403 E 12th St, Manhattan
Open · Closes 3:30 PM
+1 646-602-1300
RestaurantPoint of interestFood
Helen
An upscale American restaurant strongly influenced by Italian cuisine. Hearth is open for dinner only. Expect …
Karen
Upscale Tuscan-American restaurant. Exquisite food right a block away! You will love the desserts!
3. Hearth
3. Hearth
host-0host-1
0 local reviews
403 E 12th St, Manhattan
Open · Closes 3:30 PM
+1 646-602-1300
Helen
Helen
An upscale American restaurant strongly influenced by Italian cuisine. Hearth is open for dinner only. Expect to pay roughly $80/person, inc…
Karen
Karen
Upscale Tuscan-American restaurant. Exquisite food right a block away! You will love the desserts!
4. Mayfield
4. Mayfield
host-0host-1host-2
0 local reviews
688 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn
Open · Closes 3:00 PM
+1 347-318-3643
RestaurantPoint of interestFood
Joshua
Mayfield is a stylish New American restaurant serving trendy dishes and some unexpected items in a large space…
Leo
Spacious New American restaurant serving trendy eats & less-expected items in vintage-inspired digs.
Lexia
Spacious new american restaurant serving trendy eats & less-expected items in vintage-inspired digs.
4. Mayfield
4. Mayfield
host-0host-1host-2
0 local reviews
688 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn
Open · Closes 3:00 PM
+1 347-318-3643
Joshua
Joshua
Mayfield is a stylish New American restaurant serving trendy dishes and some unexpected items in a large space with vintage-inspired decor. …
Leo
Leo
Spacious New American restaurant serving trendy eats & less-expected items in vintage-inspired digs.
Lexia
Lexia
Spacious new american restaurant serving trendy eats & less-expected items in vintage-inspired digs.
5. Eugene & Company
5. Eugene & Company
host-0host-1
0 local reviews
397 Tompkins Ave, Brooklyn
Open · Closes 12:00 AM (midnight)
+1 718-443-2223
BarRestaurantPoint of interest
Joe And Jeff
A cool New American restaurant. Friendly atmosphere and great food.
Rebecca And Vilem
New American Restaurant
5. Eugene & Company
5. Eugene & Company
host-0host-1
0 local reviews
397 Tompkins Ave, Brooklyn
Open · Closes 12:00 AM (midnight)
+1 718-443-2223
Joe And Jeff
Joe And Jeff
A cool New American restaurant. Friendly atmosphere and great food.
Rebecca And Vilem
Rebecca And Vilem
New American Restaurant
6. Olmsted
6. Olmsted
host-0host-1
0 local reviews
659 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn
Open · Closes in 22 minutes
+1 718-552-2610
RestaurantPoint of interestFood
Jean
American restaurant by a chef-farmer team growing many ingredients in its backyard garden.
Leo
American restaurant by a chef-farmer team growing many ingredients in its backyard garden. If you are looking …
6. Olmsted
6. Olmsted
host-0host-1
0 local reviews
659 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn
Open · Closes in 22 minutes
+1 718-552-2610
Jean
Jean
American restaurant by a chef-farmer team growing many ingredients in its backyard garden.
Leo
Leo
American restaurant by a chef-farmer team growing many ingredients in its backyard garden. If you are looking for one of the best dining exp…