Holiday rentals in Sugar City

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Sugar City

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favourite

A spacious sleeping area features a large bed with soft linens and multiple accent pillows. Two bedside tables hold lamps, providing a warm glow. Sheer curtains frame the window, allowing natural light to enhance the light green walls and wooden floor.

Cottage in Rexburg

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 393 reviews

Garden Loft - Beautiful, Private, Country Setting!

We live on 14 beautiful acres with walking paths, groves of trees, a beautiful pond, and horses and cows all around us. During your stay, you will enjoy the quietness of the country, but quick easy access to town, Walmart is just 7 minutes away. The Loft is cozy with a wonderful view out every window. It is the perfect home base for your day trips to Yellowstone, the Teton Valley, Jackson Hole, Yellowstone Safari Park (1 min Away), Bear World, the St. Anthony Sand Dunes, or visiting BYU-Idaho.

Top guest favourite

The inviting entrance features a covered porch supported by stone columns. A wooden door with a window is complemented by two seating chairs. Decorative pumpkins add a seasonal touch, while a well-manicured lawn can be seen in front.

Home in Rexburg

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 352 reviews

Luxurious Modern 3-Bed 2-Bath Home near BYU-Idaho

Enjoy a luxurious stay at our farmhouse-style cottage conveniently located near many Rexburg amenities (BYU-Idaho, Hospital, Smith Park, LDS Temple, Waterpark). Perfect affordable home base for adventures to Yellowstone, Grand Teton, Jackson, and Targhee. Recently finished with modern touches, the spaces are all on one level and include a well-stocked kitchen, comfortable beds, clean bathrooms, and a spacious back deck. Our amazing on-site property managers live in a separate basement apartment.

Guest favourite

A comfortable living area features a dark leather sofa accompanied by two patterned armchairs. A cozy throw blanket is draped over the sofa. The room is accented by a decorative fireplace and ample natural light streaming through the window blinds.

Home in Sugar City

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Charming home by BYUI, Sand Dunes & Nat’l Park’s.

Relax in this charming home with the whole family at this peaceful location.. Plenty of free parking off the street. Large beautiful yard with swings for the kids to play. There is a covered patio with a grill. Great base for hunting, fishing, boating, hiking, skiing, snowmobiling, 4 wheeling etc. BYU-Idaho University and the Rexburg Temple are 3 miles away. 10 miles from St. Anthony Sand. Dunes. 1 hour and 1/2 from Yellowstone and Teton National Parks. Walmart is located 1 mile mile away.

Guest favourite

Guest suite in Sugar City

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 421 reviews

Suite with Private Entrance Garage and Theater

Welcome! We believe you will enjoy this private guest suite, with 3 beds, family room with movie theater and dining area, fridge, coffee machine, microwave (NO kitchen). This suite is centrally located for easy travel to Jackson, Yellowstone, Grand Targhee, Bear World, Craters of the Moon, and the Sand Dunes. We can be found just off HWY 20 and not far from HWY 33. We are just 4 minutes from Rexburg, Idaho with BYU-Idaho, Walmart, and many restaurants. We know you will have a memorable stay.

Top guest favourite

An open living space features a kitchenette with light blue cabinetry and a granite countertop. A dining area is created with two white stools positioned at the counter. A spacious bed with a patterned blanket is set against a large window with natural light filtering in.

Tiny home in Sugar City

5 out of 5 average rating, 212 reviews

Ninette’s She Shed

Discover the gorgeous landscape that surrounds this place to stay. We are 1:15 from the West Yellowstone west entrance and Jackson Hole Wyoming. We are also 1:45 minutes from Teton Teton National Park. In the winter you can drive 45 minutes to get to the Grand Targhee Ski resort. The resort has amazing powder to ski on in the winter and incredible scenic hikes to discover in the fall and summer. This tiny house is perfect for 2 people. Brand new 500 square feet of comfy country living.

Guest favourite

An open-concept living area showcases hickory hardwood floors and exposed brick walls. A dining table with black chairs is positioned beside a modern kitchen equipped with stainless steel appliances. A comfortable seating area is visible with a gray couch and a decorative clock on the wall.

Flat in Rexburg

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

Historic Liberty Flats Apt 1 in downtown Rexburg

Enjoy a stylish and urban experience at this newly remodeled and centrally-located apartment, complete with premium finishes like hickory hardwood floors, granite countertops, and authentic exposed brick walls. Only a few blocks from BYU-I, great restaurants, the grocery store, and the hospital. Is an excellent place to stay while visiting college students, stopping on your way to Yellowstone or Grand Teton National Park, or for posting up for a while to enjoy East Idaho’s great outdoors.

Guest favourite

A spacious sleeping area is highlighted by a large wooden bed frame with a comfortable mattress. Two bedside lamps provide soft lighting, while a bench is positioned at the foot of the bed. Natural light filters in through the nearby window, complementing the open layout.

Flat in Rexburg

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 324 reviews

Spa Jetted shower & soaker tub Modern Studio

This open & refreshing modern studio apartment is a block from Porter Park & 3 blocks from BYU-Idaho campus. The moment you walk in the apartment you feel the soft light from the huge windows & wonder... is this really a basement? You’ll find a luxury bathroom outfitted with body jets, rain shower & deep soaker tub filled by waterfall spout. The bed is wonderfully comfortable with fluffy breathable topper. You can even snuggle up to the fire or enjoy your favorite shows on the smart TV!

Top guest favourite

An outdoor patio area features a covered space with wooden beams and soft lighting. A comfortable seating arrangement is paired with a coffee table, while a dining table with chairs occupies the adjacent space. Large windows allow natural light to enter the home.

Home in Sugar City

5 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Haven House - Top Rated Stay in East, ID

🏆 TOP RATED PROPERTY IN EASTERN, ID ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Haven House is rated the best stay experience in the region by our guests!!! 🗺️ Centered between the region's national parks (1hr to YELLOWSTONE, GRAND TARGHEE RESORT, JACKSON HOLE) & 10 min to BYU- I. 🏟️👩‍🍳🔥🛁 Enjoy foosball/air hockey in the game area, a gourmet kitchen loaded with extras, cozy back porch with a toasty fire pit, or the Spa style Master Bath and soak tub! Enjoy the best AIRBNB stay experience in Eastern ID.

Top guest favourite

A comfortable living space is shown, featuring a large flat-screen TV mounted on a light-colored wall. Two brown reclining chairs and a plush sofa are arranged on a soft carpet. A wooden dining table for four is positioned near a window, allowing natural light to fill the room.

Home in Rexburg

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Bev's Place

Welcome to Bev's place, where you can enjoy a great night stay in a wonderful location just 10 minutes away from BYU Idaho, 1 hour and 20 minutes to Yellowstone and 15 minutes away from the St. Anthony sand dunes. You will enjoy a country living feel in this spacious two story home located just north of Rexburg. With parking available on site you can bring your toys and enjoy recreating in the beautiful surrounding areas that South East Idaho has to offer.

Top guest favourite

The guest suite is shown in a charming exterior view, featuring light-colored siding and a gabled roof. A well-maintained lawn with green grass and blooming flowers is visible in the foreground, alongside a tall evergreen tree providing a natural border.

Home in Rexburg

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 210 reviews

Country Cottage Guest Suite

This cozy 1 bdrm, 1 bath guest suite is attached to our family home but has a separate locked entrance and offers complete privacy. Our quiet country neighborhood is located in beautiful Idaho farmland. Enjoy jam from our garden and a stroll to the neighborhood lake. We're 15 min from BYU-Idaho, 1.5 hrs from Yellowstone NP, 1.5 hrs from Jackson and Grand Teton NP, 15 min from sand dunes and about 1 hr from Grand Targhee Ski Resort.

Guest favourite

A contemporary living area features a plush gray sectional sofa and a matching armchair. A light-colored area rug covers the floor beneath a coffee table. A large TV is mounted on a white shelving unit, with decorative plants filling the background.

Home in Sugar City

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

Luxury modern home

Come relax in our New Condo! Appx 1hr to Parks (W YELLOWSTONE, GRAND TARGHEE RESORT, JACKSON HOLE) & 5 min to BYU- I. Hike nearby trails, explore the sand dunes or float the Henry’s Fork River! Fully stocked kitchen, games for the family and some toys for the little ones. Smart TV in the main area. Wind the day down by soaking in the Spa style Master Bath! ALL bedrooms are upstairs, this home is not ADA compliant or accessible.

Top guest favourite

A spacious master suite features a comfortable queen bed with a light-colored quilt and decorative pillow. French doors open to a private deck, enhancing the connection to nature. A bedside lamp provides soft lighting, and a serene view of green foliage is visible through the open doors.

Guest suite in Sugar City

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 544 reviews

Relaxing Master Suite with Private Entrance

Welcome to our home!!! We hope you will enjoy this completely private, beautiful and comfortable master suite. This location is centrally located for trips to Yellowstone, Jackson, Grand Targhee, the Sand Dunes and Craters of the Moon. We are located just minutes off Hwy 20 which leads to Yellowstone and close to Hwy 33 which leads to Jackson and the Tetons. We are within four miles of BYU Idaho, Walmart & many restaurants.