Holiday rentals in Schuyler Lake

*Oaks Creek Cottage*ON the Creek*3bd 2bath Sleeps6

*RENT FROM A LOCAL!* Welcome to Oaks Creek Cottage in Fly Creek!!! This adorable 3 bed 2 bath house is RIGHT on Oaks Creek! Go 1 mile down the road to the Fly Creek General Store and grab a fishing pole! Also included is a fire pit, outdoor charcoal grill, outdoor games like corn hole, Jenga, Connect 4 and ring toss. This place is made for the outdoors! 4.5 miles to the Baseball Hall of Fame 7.3 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park 24 miles to All Star Village 12 miles to Glimmerglass Opera House

Turtle Cove*ON Oaks Creek!*Fish&Swim!

Nestled in the serene and picturesque setting of Fly Creek, this brand-new home offers modern comforts, spacious living, and breathtaking natural views with Oaks Creek running across the back of the property. Turtle Cove earned its name from the plentiful amount of turtles that make their home there in the pond and creek and are seen throughout the spring making their nests along the soft grounds. There are 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms and an additional bonus room with a daybed to sleep 8 people

Cooperstown 5BR | Wiffle Field, Hot Tub, Lake View

Cooperstown Sports Lodge at Lakeview Point is a spacious, private retreat featuring beautiful lake views, a vaulted-ceiling living room with a massive fireplace, a fully loaded game room, and plenty of room for groups with 4 bedrooms plus a bunkroom. Across 15 secluded acres of outdoor space you will find a hot tub, fire pit, outdoor dining, a 9 hole Bucket Golf course, and a wiffle ball mini-stadium. It's the perfect place to relax, recharge, and enjoy the best of the Cooperstown area.

"Just an Ol' Farm House"

Charming COUNTRY farm house dates back to pre-civil war times, this evident by the beautiful wood work, beautiful wide plank floors. Large yard that is perfect for the kids or dog to run & play. This house is in the perfect central location of the NY COUNRY side. THERE ARE ZERO STREET LIGHTS. We are short drive to many attractions around NY. You have the entire house to yourself & your party. We are close if you need us but we value your privacy! *Please read pet policy carefully*

Historic home, barn life and great views!

Pack up your family and come stay in our charming 1835 Federal-style stone home located just 9 miles outside of Cooperstown, 1/2 hour to Cooperstown All Star Field and 20 minutes to Cooperstown Dream Park. The home boasts 4 large bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, 2 living rooms, kitchen and a dining room. The property sits on 70 acres and has a 1/2 acre of the yard fully groomed for the perfect baseball game. It also features a beautiful barn outfitted with a dining area, pool table and TV.

Cedar Lake Cottage

This cozy cottage is nestled in a tranquil setting, with glorious golf course and lake views offering an escape from the fast pace of everyday life. The screened-in front porch provides the opportunity to relax on the couch or dine at the spacious banquette, all while taking in the beauty of the Upstate New York surroundings. With its proximity to several universities and local attractions, this cottage keeps you connected while offering a wonderfully peaceful getaway.

Luxury Cooperstown Area Lake Home with Amenities!!

2027 Summer Bookings open 10/1, we only accept 6 night stays aligned with “Cooperstown Dreams Park” schedule, see their site for schedule. “Allstar Village” schedule does not align with us. The 2027 season is 5/30-8/22/26. Beautiful 3 bedroom on Canadarago Lake, 15 min. drive to Cooperstown. We now have 6 kayaks, a pedal boat, & a paddle board! Enjoy coffee viewing the peacefulness of the lake, if mornings aren’t for you, It is as beautiful at sunset with wine.

Fly Creek Guesthouse

Escape to the Fly Creek Guesthouse, a peaceful countryside stay in Fly Creek just minutes from Cooperstown, local museums, shops, breweries, and more. Features include a spacious living/dining area, full kitchen, washer/dryer, efficient bathroom, and loft sleeping area with king and queen beds. Whether you’re visiting for baseball, Glimmerglass, or simply a quiet escape in Central New York, the Fly Creek Guesthouse offers a warm and peaceful home base close to it all.

An Upstate NY getaway treasure!

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. For several hundred years our family has been a part of the Cooperstown community and we look forward to sharing it with you! On over 20 acres of land , you can explore the beautiful landscape of water and woods. Just over the hill from Otsego Lake. Only 3.9 miles (8 min) to Cooperstown’s Main Street in the spring, summer and fall and 5.7 miles (10 min) in winter.

Creekside of the Moon A-frame Cabin

Creekside of the moon A-frame glamp. Float, fish and play in the Catskills. Glamp on the Charlotte Creek in a newly built modern tiny a-frame. Sleep under the full moon. A giant moon light hangs over the bed(s) with a stunning reflection in the window at night over the creekview. Perfect for a romantic getaway, fishing trip, or glamping spot in the Catskills. Close to Cooperstown, NY IG @aframe_moon

The Hillside House

Step inside to this Bright, modern home with forest views. Features two bedrooms (one queen, one full) and two full baths—perfect for families, couples, or small groups. Enjoy sleek finishes, large windows, and a peaceful grassy clearing ideal for relaxing or stargazing. Conveniently located just 8 miles from Dreams Park, 20 miles from All-Star Village, and 4 miles from historic Cooperstown.

Farm stay w/ Alpaca walk included @ The Stead

Welcome to "THE STEAD" @ Lyons Family Homestead. A unique secluded tiny home nestled up on the hill of our 19-acre farm. Surrounded by nature and lots of friendly animals. We created this space as a place to escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. We encourage you to unplug and unwind as you soak in life on the farm here.