Guidebook for Mastic

J & F
Guidebook for Mastic

Essentials

FISH MARKET: A must if you like seafood. Fresh seafood at very low prices. Lobster, all kinds of fish, clams, mussels, etc, and delicious (pre-made) seafood salad. Fluke is great in summer!
8 locals recommend
Mastic Seafood
1051 Mastic Rd
8 locals recommend
FISH MARKET: A must if you like seafood. Fresh seafood at very low prices. Lobster, all kinds of fish, clams, mussels, etc, and delicious (pre-made) seafood salad. Fluke is great in summer!
For all of your grocery needs. They have a small natural food section as well. Great produce!
20 locals recommend
Stop & Shop
999 Montauk Hwy
20 locals recommend
For all of your grocery needs. They have a small natural food section as well. Great produce!
Great for stopping by on the way to or from the beach!
15 locals recommend
King Kullen
405 William Floyd Pkwy
15 locals recommend
Great for stopping by on the way to or from the beach!
Beer distributor, good for purchasing beer in bulk.
Smith Point Beverage Inc
160 Margin Dr W
Beer distributor, good for purchasing beer in bulk.
For spirits and wine.
Southport Spirits
999-2 Montauk Hwy
For spirits and wine.
Stop at The Village Cheese Shop in Mattituck after some wine tasting! Great cheese and olive oils.
26 locals recommend
The Village Cheese Shop & Café
105 Love Ln
26 locals recommend
Stop at The Village Cheese Shop in Mattituck after some wine tasting! Great cheese and olive oils.
Great selection of beer!
1426 Montauk Hwy
1426 Montauk Highway
Great selection of beer!
A good staple.
62 locals recommend
Trader Joe's
400 Post Rd E
62 locals recommend
A good staple.

Food Scene

Delicious chinese take-out - call ahead for pickup or ask for delivery.
Foo Sing Kitchen
1495 Montauk Hwy
Delicious chinese take-out - call ahead for pickup or ask for delivery.
Originally only a Chinese restaurant, they recently remodeled and added an extensive sushi menu to their selection - all very delicious.
Tony's
77 Northern Blvd
Originally only a Chinese restaurant, they recently remodeled and added an extensive sushi menu to their selection - all very delicious.
Order to pick up, or stay and eat. Our absolute favorite is the Grandma pie (get it well done) - great for picking up and enjoying at home. Another great pie is the white pizza with sausage.
Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina
201 Mastic Beach Rd
Order to pick up, or stay and eat. Our absolute favorite is the Grandma pie (get it well done) - great for picking up and enjoying at home. Another great pie is the white pizza with sausage.
The best italian ices in all of New York. Huge selection of flavors, a must for summertime. NOTE: They moved to a new location in May 2015, across from Stop & Shop on Montauk Highway in Shirley.
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices & Ice Cream
990 Montauk Highway
The best italian ices in all of New York. Huge selection of flavors, a must for summertime. NOTE: They moved to a new location in May 2015, across from Stop & Shop on Montauk Highway in Shirley.
Excellent falafel, souvlaki, gyro and Greek iced coffee.
10 locals recommend
Greek Bites Grill & Cafe
183 Montauk Hwy
10 locals recommend
Excellent falafel, souvlaki, gyro and Greek iced coffee.
Delicious food in a cottage style house. Very cozy atmosphere.
38 locals recommend
The Bellport
159 S Country Rd
38 locals recommend
Delicious food in a cottage style house. Very cozy atmosphere.
Awesome mussels and soup. Get the mussels!
13 locals recommend
Varney's Restaurant
2109 Montauk Hwy
13 locals recommend
Awesome mussels and soup. Get the mussels!
Solid italian. The pastas are all delicious.
25 locals recommend
Mama Lisa Restaurant
1226 Montauk Hwy
25 locals recommend
Solid italian. The pastas are all delicious.
Italian - good.
16 locals recommend
La Volpe
611 Main St
16 locals recommend
Italian - good.
Very good and close to the Tanger Outlet mall! Try calling in for reservations.
55 locals recommend
Farm Country Kitchen
513 W Main St
55 locals recommend
Very good and close to the Tanger Outlet mall! Try calling in for reservations.
Craving Mexican? Stop here after shopping at Tanger Outlets to refuel.
8 locals recommend
FUNCHOS certified tacologist
1156 W Main St
8 locals recommend
Craving Mexican? Stop here after shopping at Tanger Outlets to refuel.
Delicious seafood! Outdoor seating. Only 20 minutes away; near Tanger Outlet mall. If you love seafood and don't feel like cooking, this is a great place.
10 locals recommend
Buoy One - Riverhead
1175 W Main St
10 locals recommend
Delicious seafood! Outdoor seating. Only 20 minutes away; near Tanger Outlet mall. If you love seafood and don't feel like cooking, this is a great place.
Great pies if you're in the area. The clam pizza is great. Casual dining with just a few seats.
28 locals recommend
Brunetti Pizza
61 Main St
28 locals recommend
Great pies if you're in the area. The clam pizza is great. Casual dining with just a few seats.
Best coffee in town. Great pastries. Reminds us of Brooklyn. :) Incl. organic products.
15 locals recommend
Tend Coffee
924 Montauk Hwy
15 locals recommend
Best coffee in town. Great pastries. Reminds us of Brooklyn. :) Incl. organic products.
Empanadas are excellent. Great for a snack, a meal, on the beach or off. More of a takeout place than dien-in. They have a wide selection of flavors.
8 locals recommend
EmpanadaVille
374 Neighborhood Rd
8 locals recommend
Empanadas are excellent. Great for a snack, a meal, on the beach or off. More of a takeout place than dien-in. They have a wide selection of flavors.
One of our favorites in Long Island. Authentic Turkish cuisine run by a lovely family. Everything on the menu is great!
21 locals recommend
Turkuaz Grill
40 McDermott Ave
21 locals recommend
One of our favorites in Long Island. Authentic Turkish cuisine run by a lovely family. Everything on the menu is great!
Best bagels in the area - great for mornings when you don't feel like cooking!
7 locals recommend
Freshy Fresh Bagels
917 Montauk Hwy
7 locals recommend
Best bagels in the area - great for mornings when you don't feel like cooking!
Good seafood. 2 locations: Westhampton and Riverhead, both good.
20 locals recommend
Buoy One
62 Montauk Hwy
20 locals recommend
Good seafood. 2 locations: Westhampton and Riverhead, both good.
Mexican - seafood.
159 locals recommend
RUMBA Inspired Island Cuisine & Rum Bar
43 Canoe Place Rd
159 locals recommend
Mexican - seafood.
Great casual seafood restarant + seafood market.
26 locals recommend
Out of the Blue Seafood
252 East Montauk Highway
26 locals recommend
Great casual seafood restarant + seafood market.
Great setting for a nice seafood meal.
201 locals recommend
Cowfish
258 E Montauk Hwy
201 locals recommend
Great setting for a nice seafood meal.
Delicious sushi + festive hibachi. We've enjoyed all the sushi rolls we've ever had there.
6 locals recommend
Sumou
760 Montauk Hwy
6 locals recommend
Delicious sushi + festive hibachi. We've enjoyed all the sushi rolls we've ever had there.
If you feel like Korean, this is probably the best you're going to find in Long Island (run by Koreans). Not quite as good as Koreatown in Manhattan, but decent.
Ssambap Korean BBQ
2350 Nesconset Hwy
If you feel like Korean, this is probably the best you're going to find in Long Island (run by Koreans). Not quite as good as Koreatown in Manhattan, but decent.
Delicious Thai food. Really good, better than most places in Manhattan even. The owner is really nice.
Raan Thai
203 Terry Rd
Delicious Thai food. Really good, better than most places in Manhattan even. The owner is really nice.
Good bagels.
Moriches Bagel Deli Inc
329 Main St
Good bagels.

Shopping

One of our favorite places to find antique goods. Bring cash.
The Beer Store of Long Island
1426 County Rd 80
One of our favorite places to find antique goods. Bring cash.
Enjoy a fun day at the mall! Full list of stores here: http://www.tangeroutlet.com/riverhead/directory
Tanger Factory Outlet Center
Enjoy a fun day at the mall! Full list of stores here: http://www.tangeroutlet.com/riverhead/directory

Sightseeing

The beach - it's why you came. Miles and miles of sand and ocean. East end of Fire Island. Accessible via a driveable bridge. Large parking lot ($15/day parking).
8 locals recommend
Smith Point
8 locals recommend
The beach - it's why you came. Miles and miles of sand and ocean. East end of Fire Island. Accessible via a driveable bridge. Large parking lot ($15/day parking).
Large visitor center and miles of nature trails along the Carmen's River. Great for hiking, bird watching, or bring your canoe or kayak.
23 locals recommend
Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge
340 Smith Road
23 locals recommend
Large visitor center and miles of nature trails along the Carmen's River. Great for hiking, bird watching, or bring your canoe or kayak.
Great for catching the sunset. Also a small beach with very calm water (great for kids).
Shirley Beach
18 Grandview Dr
Great for catching the sunset. Also a small beach with very calm water (great for kids).
Great for hiking, running, bird watching. Small beach on the bay at the end of the hike/run - just beautiful.
19 locals recommend
Terrell River County Park
43 Montauk Hwy
19 locals recommend
Great for hiking, running, bird watching. Small beach on the bay at the end of the hike/run - just beautiful.
Performances and off-Broadway shows.
28 locals recommend
Gateway Playhouse
215 S Country Rd
28 locals recommend
Performances and off-Broadway shows.

Drinks & Nightlife

Pelligrini is a winery (not a bar) and has an amazing setting.
16 locals recommend
Pellegrini Vineyards
23005 Main Rd
16 locals recommend
Pelligrini is a winery (not a bar) and has an amazing setting.
Jamesport has my favorite Pinot Noir. Definitely worth a visit. (this is a winery, not a bar).
56 locals recommend
Jamesport Vineyards
New York 25
56 locals recommend
Jamesport has my favorite Pinot Noir. Definitely worth a visit. (this is a winery, not a bar).
Shinn is the almost all organic winery. Great! (This is not a bar).
34 locals recommend
Shinn Estate Vineyards and Farmhouse
2000 Oregon Rd
34 locals recommend
Shinn is the almost all organic winery. Great! (This is not a bar).
Winery: A visit to Lenz winery is a must since he is the winemaster of the region.
28 locals recommend
Lenz Winery
38355 NY-25
28 locals recommend
Winery: A visit to Lenz winery is a must since he is the winemaster of the region.

Everything Else

Great grocery store - freshest bread in town and great produce.
8 locals recommend
Best Market Shirley
800 Montauk Hwy
8 locals recommend
Great grocery store - freshest bread in town and great produce.
Right across from Trader Joe's. Double whammy grocery shopping, and right next to the mall!
54 locals recommend
Whole Foods Market
90 E Putnam Ave
54 locals recommend
Right across from Trader Joe's. Double whammy grocery shopping, and right next to the mall!

Arts & Culture

Stylish contemporary American art museum. http://parrishart.org/
263 locals recommend
Parrish Art Museum
279 Montauk Hwy
263 locals recommend
Stylish contemporary American art museum. http://parrishart.org/