Skip to content

Top restaurant recommendations from locals

Restaurant
“Hugely popular because it's so darn good! And right on Main st in Narrowsburg, the uber chic town on The Delaware River.”
  • 62 locals recommend
Restaurant
$$$
“[COCHECTON - approx. 10 min drive] An absolute must in the cold-weather months. Ski chalet-like interiors and hearty dishes make this an area favorite. Located above the gas station (but don't let that fool you -- it's great!)”
  • 36 locals recommend
Bar
“Callicoon Brewing Company started in the old Callicoon firehouse and has made its way to the historic Olympia Hotel diagonal from its origin. Fun...very local bar that the whole family can enjoy. Great place to take pictures from the porch!”
  • 34 locals recommend
Gastropub
$$
“A lovely little restaurant with occasional live music. Check in advance if reservations are needed.”
  • 26 locals recommend
Resort
“Good food in a cozy downstairs pub style tavern room, located in Livingston Manor NY a little ways out of town. Worth a visit. www.thearnoldhouse.com”
  • 29 locals recommend
Bar
“Fantastic pizza! Really great place! And their beer is pretty swell too. Drink responsibly, please.”
  • 30 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“A charming restaurant that serves simple but elegant flare with a twist of local history. Live music on weekends and Live Jazz Brunch on Sundays.”
  • 31 locals recommend
Sandwich Place
$$
“Main Street Farm in Livingston Manor NY offers organic and local produce and food products, including trout, chicken and beef, as well as sandwiches and prepared foods in its cafe section. www.mainstreetfarm.com”
  • 31 locals recommend
Pizza Place
$
“Wood fired pizza along the Delaware River? Yup, it doesn't get any better than this!”
  • 36 locals recommend
Pub
$
“Great spot in Livingston Manor for excellent pizza, wings and cocktails. The outdoor area has a great bonfire and a gelato airstreamer!”
  • 29 locals recommend
Bar
$$
“[BETHEL-approx. 15 min drive] Great food and an outstanding distillery conveniently located across the road from the Woodstock Museum. ”
  • 18 locals recommend
Restaurant
“Looks like a bar, but has a nice restaurant in the back. Outdoor deck dining. ”
  • 23 locals recommend
Bed & Breakfast
“Enjoy a farm to table meal and show off your skills at bowling on the vintage lanes located in the restaurant. ”
  • 15 locals recommend
Bar
“If you need something closer to home but still delicious try Gaby's Cafe. Traditional Mexican restaurant with the freshest ingredients and lively ambiance. Mariachi band any one??!! ”
  • 11 locals recommend
Pizza Place
$$
“Great Italian restaurant! Right in Callicoon. Grab some Pizza and get to the movies!”
  • 20 locals recommend
Bar
“Farm to table gastropub with craft beer menu, featuring live music on select nights. Located in Hurleyville, NY, near the Sullivan County Historical Society. Casual. www.pickledowl.com”
  • 8 locals recommend