Holiday rentals in Shelbyville

Atop The Shop II | Spacious Downtown Loft

Atop the Shop II is a beautifully restored 1,800 SF loft in the heart of Downtown Shelbyville. This spacious apartment blends modern amenities with the character of a century-old building, giving you the best of comfort and charm. With plenty of room for families or groups to spread out and relax, it’s perfect for lake weekends, weddings, or a simple getaway. Less than a block from restaurants & shops, and just a mile from Lake Shelbyville. Historic charm. Modern comfort. Unbeatable location.

Game Room | Hot Tub | Fire Pit @ Lake Shelbyville

Sitting just one mile outside city limits & 2 minutes to Lake Shelbyville, is this beautifully appointed home waiting for guests to enjoy all of its amenities; pool table, fire pit, grilling area, corn hole set, and hot tub. Inside, nothing was held back when it came to decorating this home for a truly relaxing experience. All the amenities of home are here just waiting for you to arrive, relax, and enjoy. We are sure you will rest easy in this boutique style home located at Lake Shelbyville.

Asa Creek Cottage

This open concept cottage offers the perfect blend of nature and modern comfort for families and small group gatherings. Enjoy the creek side deck, and listen to the gentle sound of the little waterfall nearby. On cooler evenings, gather around the fire to warm up. The interior boasts a spacious design, close to The Little Theatre on the Square, walking trails, and Lake Shelbyville with boating, fishing and swimming. Relax with a modern kitchen, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and a rainfall shower.

A Novel Stay

Enjoy peace and nature in this 3 bd 2 bath log cabin located on 3.5 acres of wooded property just a few minutes from Lithia Marina at Lake Shelbyville, IL. This home features a fully stocked kitchen, Blackstone, 6 person hot tub and large solo fire pit. It comfortably sleeps 8 and can flex up to 11, if needed. There are 3 Roku Tv's, bluetooth speakers and many family friendly games for your use. Come stay at a Novel Stay "Into the forest I go, to lose my mind and find my soul".- John Muir

Prairieview Cottage Retreat - Hot Tub Sunsets

REST, RELAX, RETREAT... Escape to tranquility at this picturesque, pet-friendly cottage, nestled in the serene countryside. Whether you're coming for a romantic retreat, family getaway, or a solo sanctuary, this charming haven offers a wonderful blend of comfort and serenity. Enjoy stunning sunsets from the hot tub, cozy up by the firepit on the patio, or simply unwind indoors in comfort. This retreat is ideally located in the heart of Illinois Amish country and near Lake Shelbyville.

Lakefront Cottage • Dock, Kayaks, Fire Pit & Beach

Welcome! Imagine waking up ten steps from the water, kayak paddles already calling your name. The Lake House on Lake Sara puts you right at the edge of the lake — with four kayaks, a crackling fire pit, and a sunlit enclosed porch to come home to. The Lake House is located just a short walk to the Beach, Pinky’s , The Rusty Reel Bar (below Pinky’s) and The Marina. The beach offers a beautiful playground, pavilions, exercise equipment, pickleball courts and a frisbee golf course!

The Bin at No Bad Days farm

The Bin at No Bad Days farm is a newly constructed grain bin. As you walk in checkout the beautiful craftsmanship on the ceiling! There is a loft upstairs where you will find a king size bed. There is also an oversized chair that converts to a small bed as well. Main floor has a sofa sleeper for two. There is a kitchenette and full bath. We know you will enjoy the rustic look of this unique property. We are 5 minutes from Lithia Springs Marina and we have room to park a boat!

Our Dam House

Unbeatable location less than 1/2 mile from the 9th Street boat ramp, 9th Street Beach, and Forest Park. Also ideal for those attending events at the Chautauqua, or Sunken Gardens. Enjoy a king bed & master bath with jacuzzi tub, a loft with a queen bed and a balcony overlooking the lake, and another bedroom with a queen bed overlooking the spacious back yard where deer come to eat. Our cozy living room has a gas fireplace. The driveway can accommodate boat trailers.

Poppy’s Place- cozy home centrally located

Be our guest at Poppy’s Place in this quiet, quaint neighborhood all while enjoying easy access to everything from this centrally located home. Close to Forest Park (Shelbyville Aquatic Center, Disc Golf, Fishing, Chautauqua Building, etc), Lake Shelbyville, downtown shopping and eating, and walking/bike trails. Enjoy a coffee while sitting on the spacious porches surrounding the home or venture out to explore this historic town.

Cottage on Lake Paradise,

Welcome to Paradise Cottage nestled on Lake Paradise! Cozy and warm with wood finishes throughout. Includes three-tiered deck/patio, with the lowest level sitting over the water. Perfect for fishing (this lake hosts an annual fishing tournament), canoeing/kayaking, or just relaxing. Great for bird watching, with great blue herons, egrets, ducks, bald eagles, plovers, cormorants, woodpeckers and other species seen daily.

Cozy 1-bed Charming Apartment

Welcome to our cozy one-bedroom apartment in Shelbyville, the perfect place for your next visit to this charming town! Designed for comfort and convenience, this apartment features a queen-sized bed, a spacious living room for relaxing, and all the essential amenities you need for a hassle-free stay, including air conditioning, high-speed Wi-Fi, and a full-size washer and dryer.

One bedroom apartment above garage

One bedroom apartment above a garage in a small, quiet town. There is not much to do in our town but it has a wonderful park, a gas station, bank, and a family friendly bar that serves pizza and a few other items. We are located 20 minutes from Shelbyville, Effingham, and Mattoon. 20 % off per night for stays longer than 7 nights.