Skip to content
Entire flat

The Case-Jennings House on Shelter Island

The Case-Jennings House on Shelter Island

4 guests
2 bedrooms
2 beds
1 bath
4 guests
2 bedrooms
2 beds
1 bath

The Case-Jennings House is a beautiful Shelter Island gem. "Anna's Cottage" was built in 1847 and stands proudly as one of the island's oldest homes.
In the same family for four generations, this two-bedroom treasure was newly renovated and restored in 2017. It is dressed in contemporary farmhouse decor and located within one mile of restaurants, shops, the beach, ferry and a golf course. This immaculate and comfortable space is ready to welcome you to the simpler way of Shelter Island life.

Amenities

Kitchen
Wifi
Free parking on premises
Indoor fireplace
Cable TV
Washer

Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1
1 queen bed
Bedroom 2
1 queen bed

House Rules

No smoking
Not suitable for pets
No parties or events
Check-in time is 3PM - 12AM (midnight)
Self check-in with keypad

36 Reviews

Accuracy
Communication
Cleanliness
Location
Check-in
Value
April User Profile
April
May 2018
Florence was an amazing host. She made us feel very welcome and checked in through out our stay to make sure we were comfortable.
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
Hosting April and Remy was such a pleasure! They were friendly, considerate, respectful, tidy and clean; the house was left in perfect order. I highly recommend them as guests and would welcome them again without hesitation! Thank you for being Super Guests! Florence
May 2018
Ariel User Profile
Ariel
May 2018
Awesome place! The location is amazing and it's so peaceful. The house is very clean and comfortable. Florence is a amazing host. She is super sweet, thoughtful and keeps the place immaculate! Will plan to stay again when we come back
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
Meeting and welcoming Ariel, Alex, Louise and Dan to my grandparent's home and Shelter Island was a pleasure! They were friendly, considerate, respectful, tidy and clean; the house was left on perfect order. I highly recommend them as guests and would welcome them again without hesitation. Thank you for being Super Guests! Florence
May 2018
Wendy User Profile
Wendy
May 2018
The house was very clean. Beds were very comfortable. Each room was spacious and beautifully decorated. The kitchen was well stocked and appointed.
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
Wendy and her guests were a pleasure to host. They were quiet, respectful, considerate, tidy and clean. I highly recommend them if they request a booking and would welcome them again without hesitation! Thank you for being Super Guests! Florence
May 2018
Kim User Profile
Kim
April 2018
We had a wonderful relaxing stay at this lovely little friendly house. It's located right off the North Ferry, which we took back and forth to explore wineries on the North Fork. The ferry trip -- and Shelter Island in general -- is truly something special and we'd love to come b…
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
Kim and her guests were a pleasure to host. They were considerate, respectful of the property, tidy and clean, leaving the house in perfect order. I highly recommend Kim and would welcome her again without hesitation. Thank you for being Super Guests! Florence
April 2018
Matthew User Profile
Matthew
April 2018
Florence is a truly exceptional hostess and her attention to detail and love of the home shines through. We are lucky to have found such a great place to stay.
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
Matthew, Christina and Natalie were a pleasure to host. They were friendly, considerate, respectful, quiet, tidy and clean; the house was left spotless. Thank you! I would welcome them again without hesitation because they are Super Guests! Florence
April 2018
Alana User Profile
Alana
April 2018
We had a wonderful stay. The cottage was cozy and clean and Florence took care to leave little things like fresh flowers. She was very hospitable and we feel lucky to have found such a special place to stay.
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
Meeting and welcoming Alana, Chris and their lovely, sweet, well behaved daughters to my grandparent's home was a pleasure! They were friendly, respectful, quiet, considerate, tidy and clean. I highly recommend them as guests and would welcome them again without hesitation! Thank you for being Super Guests! Florence
April 2018
Samantha User Profile
Samantha
March 2018
Florence was a pleasure to deal with. She was proactive, attentive, caring, and detail oriented, responding to questions promptly and with great local suggestions. The cottage is quaint, cheerful, and very well kept! Shelter Island is lovely respite. The locals are warm and wel…
Florence A User Profile
Response from Florence A:
I enjoyed welcoming Samantha and her guest to my grandparent's home and Shelter Island which means so much to me. The house was left in perfect order, tidy and clean, and as guests, they were respectful, considerate and quiet. Thank you for being Super Guests! Florence
March 2018

Hosted by Florence A

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United StatesJoined in May 2017
Florence A User Profile
36 Reviews
Florence A is a SuperhostSuperhosts are experienced, highly rated hosts who are committed to providing great stays for guests.
Response rate: 100%
Response time: within an hour
Always communicate through AirbnbTo protect your payment, never transfer money or communicate outside of the Airbnb website or app.

The neighbourhood

Press the down arrow key to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Check In

Press the down arrow key to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Check Out
You won’t be charged yet

Similar listings