Holiday rentals in Mystic Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Mystic Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Superhost
Cabin in Cody
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 191 reviews

Iconic Yellowstone River Ranch

Beautiful mountain setting and a ranch that was once owned by Hall of Fame cowboy, Buck Taylor of Gunsmoke Fame & the "Yellowstone" series. Recently featured in the music video "Leave The World Behind" by Caleb Hearn. Experience complete privacy, starry nights, easy access and stunning views. The cabin is decorated in authentic cowboy style, stepping back in time but, smart tv's with cable, strong WIFI and local telephone service. Close to hiking and fishing the Clark's Fork Yellowstone River!

Guest favourite
A rustic log cabin is set within a natural landscape, featuring a wooden deck with a railing. Large windows reflect the surrounding environment, and a sturdy roof complements the cabin's earthy appearance. A tall evergreen tree stands nearby, enhancing the cabin's secluded charm.
Cabin in Red Lodge
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 265 reviews

Alpbach 1 Alpine Living 1

Rustic log cabin, with TV and WIFI, 5 miles South of Red Lodge in the Beartooth Mountains. Kitchen is completely furnished with refrigerator, dishes and cookware. Cabin has queen size bed, separate bathroom with shower, and small charcoal grill on the deck. Historic Rock Creek is adjacent to the property. The cabin is a short distance from Red Lodge Ski Mountain and surrounding hiking trails. Dogs are acceptable upon inquiry @ $10/night per dog. Room Heater. Convenient parking by cabin.

Guest favourite
A serene riverfront view showcases a cabin with large windows overlooking the Stillwater River. The exterior features red wood siding and a covered porch, while the lush green grass leads down to the water's edge, framed by tall trees and mountains in the background.
Cabin in Columbus
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

"Where The Wild Things Are" Cabin Stillwater River

Resting serenely on the Stillwater River, a Blue Ribbon trout stream in the foothills of the Beartooth Mountains, this fly fisherman’s paradise offers 2 house fly rods, 2 men’s/1 child’s waders & boots, and a fly tying station with all the materials an angler could need. Guests enjoy a bar, fire pit, darts, cards, chess, a house guitar & river views from every room! Ideal for 2 families w/ 2 queen beds (1 open to loft) & 6 loft twins! Only 40 min to Red Lodge Ski Resort w/ no lift lines!

Guest favourite
A scenic view reveals a landscape of gently rolling hills and vibrant autumn foliage. Yellow aspen trees contrast with dark green pines, creating a colorful tapestry. The distant mountains provide a serene backdrop under a soft, cloudy sky.
Cabin in Nye
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 84 reviews

Quaint 1-Bedroom cabin, with sensational views.

Sitting in the shadow of the Beartooth mountains is our family cabin. The Cabin sits atop a bluff that overlooks the Westfork of the Stillwater river and next to a former art gallery. Riverfront access is a short walk down the bluff, with great trout fishing at your fingertips. Multiple national forest access points are a very short drive, that have great recreation opportunities and even better views. Wildlife sightings are a regular occurrence, but do watch for animals on the road.

Top guest favourite
A winding road curves gently alongside a rugged rocky formation, with greenery lining the base. Tall trees and vibrant foliage contrast against the stone, while a clear blue sky overhead enhances the picturesque landscape.
Flat in Red Lodge
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 795 reviews

Secluded Rock Creek Apartment

Fully furnished apartment with complete kitchen and a great view up Rock Creek Canyon. This is a very private apartment separate from main house. 3/4 Bathroom has toilet, shower and sink...private from the rest of the apartment. Property is directly on Rock Creek and includes WiFi and smart TV. Only 5 miles from Red Lodge. Queen bed in bedroom and the couch in living room is a queen hide-a-bed. My neighbor's bedroom is only 40 feet away, so I will not accept any loud motorcycles.

Top guest favourite
The exterior of a cozy cottage features a gray-blue facade and a yellow front door. A small porch is furnished with a bench and chairs, surrounded by a well-maintained lawn. A pathway leads to the entrance, with trees and a fence visible in the background.
Home in Red Lodge
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 820 reviews

The Blue House on Broadway

My house is located right in Red Lodge, easy walking distance to shops and restaurants. The Ski Mountain is just 5 miles away. You will love Red Lodge! I don't charge a cleaning fee as I think that should be in the rental price - you can't opt out of cleaning!! I do just ask you to book in the correct number of guests that will be staying. I charge for any additional people over 2 which offsets the cleaning fee. There is only one bathroom so please take that onto account .

Guest favourite
A spacious log cabin is nestled among lush greenery, featuring a covered front porch with wooden railings and rocking chairs. Large windows provide natural light, while smooth stones and vibrant grass enhance the outdoor landscape. Surrounding trees add to the serene, wooded setting.
Home in Nye
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 80 reviews

River Island House - Riverfront Luxury & Seclusion

Enjoy private luxury in this 2-story cabin at the water's edge on a wooded island. Located on the scenic West Fork of the Stillwater River, you'll find serenity in this beautiful area. Blue-Ribbon trout fishing. Secluded, but a short drive to hiking trails, the Nye Trading Post (convenience store/gas/post office), and Carter's Camp bar/restaurant. Please note: No smoking. The Pet Fee is $50 per pet. Please contact us in advance if more than one pet. Caretaker lives nearby.

Superhost
A charming log cabin sits amidst lush greenery, framed by towering trees. The building features a sloped metal roof and large windows that invite natural light. A white door provides entry, complementing the rustic aesthetic of the structure.
Cabin in Cooke City
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews

Hi-Mark Cabin

Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat or an outdoor adventure, The Hi-Mark Cabin offers the perfect home base. The Cabin is ideally situated within walking distance to local shops, restaurants, and bars in Cooke City, and just 4 miles from the North East entrance of Yellowstone National Park, and 16 miles from the Beartooth Scenic Highway. Adventurers will appreciate the proximity to countless activities right outside their door!

Guest favourite
The exterior of Colter's Cabin is highlighted, showcasing a wooden facade with a red metal roof. A rustic bear carving and a wooden bench are visible on the porch, which features several white chairs. The property is surrounded by gravel and greenery.
Home in Cooke City
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 117 reviews

Colter's Cabin Yellowstone Getaway, Cooke City, MT

Colter's Cabin is located in beautiful Cooke City, Montana near Yellowstone National Park. We are located within walking distance to shops and restaurants in the historic town of Cooke City, MT. There are countless activities right outside your door including hiking, 4 wheeling, fishing, sight seeing, wildlife watching, skiing, snowmobiling only to name a few. You will be surrounded by beautiful scenery in any direction.

Top guest favourite
A charming cabin is positioned on a gentle hillside, featuring a green roof and a wide porch. The surrounding landscape is composed of gently rolling hills covered in lush grass, creating a serene, natural setting under a clear blue sky.
Ranch in Absarokee
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 318 reviews

Indian Rock Ranch Cozy cabin w/ Mountain View

Located in the Stillwater Valley and Beartooth foothills, we are close to many Montana adventures, including wildlife viewing, fishing, hunting, hiking, Tippet Rise, whitewater rafting, horseback riding and downhill skiing. We are 30 minutes from Red Lodge. You’ll love our cabin for its clean, comfortable, relaxing and private atmosphere where the views are unbelievable. Our comfortable cabin is great for everyone!

Top guest favourite
The exterior of a mountain cabin is visible, featuring warm wooden siding and a covered porch with seating. A grill is positioned on the porch, and a well-maintained lawn stretches out in front, bordered by tall green pines and natural scenery.
Cabin in Silver Gate
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 170 reviews

MTNLUX Guest House Sauna & Hot tub

Snowmobilers... we are located on Bannock Trail so you can sled-in/sled-out to all Cooke City trails! You'll love our brand-new 2-bedroom hideaway in the woods overlooking Soda Butte Creek. It's the perfect blend of a mountain getaway with modern conveniences, and Yellowstone National Park is minutes away. You'll also love the year-round sauna & hot-tub overlooking the creek, and the decks with spectacular views.

Guest favourite
The cabin features a distinctive A-frame design with a steeply pitched roof. A spacious deck extends from the front, surrounded by neatly manicured grass. Several trees and a picnic table can be seen in the foreground, with rolling hills in the background under a clear blue sky.
Cabin in Fishtail
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

Moose Cabin - Mountain Views - Pet Friendly

Enjoy the breathtaking view of the Beartooth Mountain Range from the comfort of your cozy cabin, while being serenaded by the soothing sounds of the rushing West Rosebud Creek. This picturesque location is perfect for nature lovers seeking a peaceful getaway. This secluded retreat is sure to recharge your senses and leave you feeling refreshed. Book your stay today to experience this tranquil haven for yourself.

Popular amenities for Mystic Lake holiday rentals