Holiday rentals in Horseshoe Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Horseshoe Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favourite
A spacious lawn is framed by natural rock formations, leading to a deck with chaise loungers. The gently sloping pathway is lined with greenery and provides access to the lakefront. In the background, a multi-level house is set against a clear blue sky.
Home in Jefferson
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Lakeside Lux and Laughs!

Newly renovated 4BR/3.5BA lakefront property with multiple sitting areas, both inside and outside, is the perfect spot for relaxing and having fun with family and friends. It boasts a full game-room in the basement, a 10-person outdoor dining table, a firepit - and a fully covered bar down by the water. Sleeps 12 and is centrally located on "main lake" affording access to local restaurants, mini-golf and retail. Short-haired / non-shedding dogs (1) allowed. This home is truly something special!

Top guest favourite
A serene landscape features a large farmhouse set against a clear blue sky, with lush green grass surrounding a tranquil pond. Reflections of trees and the farmhouse are visible on the water's surface, complemented by a rustic barn in the background.
Home in Far Hills
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Pickle Farm

Meticulously maintained private quiet gated enclave featuring a restored vintage 1800 historic farmhouse and pastoral land- 1 hour from NYC. Registered movie and film location, featured in movies, commercials, documentaries and photo shoots. Agent handles negotiations, Prices vary. Minutes to train, Hamilton Farm, Pingry , Gill & Willow schools. Willowwood Arboretum, Bamboo Brook, Natirar, Several well known golf courses surrounded by hundreds of acres of preserved open land and state park.

Guest favourite
A spacious deck features a round table surrounded by black wicker chairs beneath a tiki umbrella. The warm wooden surface overlooks serene lake views, with the shoreline and homes in the background. An outdoor seating area with dark cushions is visible to the right.
Home in Hopatcong
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Lakeside Home w/Lake Access, Dock & Water Views!

Enjoy amazing lake views from this absolutely gorgeous, modern lakeside home! Perfect destination for a mini-vacation, couples retreat or a family getaway. "La Vida Lago" is a completely furnished, single family lakeside ranch home featuring 2 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, deck, patio, private lake access and dock directly across the street. The property is perched up from the road and nestled into the mountain surrounded by trees! The ideal environment to connect w/nature, yourself and loved ones.

Top guest favourite
A castle-style retreat is showcased, featuring a whimsical dragon statue and a large chess set in the foreground. A tranquil pond with a fountain is visible, alongside a magnificent castle structure designed with classic stone elements and a welcoming entrance, all set amidst lush greenery.
Castle in East Stroudsburg
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 477 reviews

Pocono Castle: Dungeon Escape Room & Private Pond

Sleep in a Fairy Tale at Pocono Castle! Live the dream in this 2,300 sq. ft storybook retreat, where you’ll sleep like royalty in a real fairy tale castle. Unwind in luxury with a bubbling hot tub, a cedar sauna, and endless magical touches. Dress up as Kings, Queens, or Knights and explore the grounds, featuring a private one-acre pond & maybe you’ll catch a Golden Fish! With enchanting bedrooms, outdoor adventures, and unforgettable charm, this is the OMG getaway you’ve been waiting for!

Top guest favourite
A serene outdoor area features two sets of blue Adirondack chairs positioned beside a gently flowing waterfall. Lush greenery surrounds the private pond, with a distant view of a white shed and the glistening pool, creating a peaceful retreat in nature.
Home in Mendham Township
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 78 reviews

Historic Cottage with Private Pond & Pool

Step back in time to 1760 with the old world charm of Colonial America. Pre-dating our country by over a decade, our beautifully renovated 260+ year old home sits on 5 acres with a detached studio and 2 separate water features. Experience the private pond teeming with koi, frogs, and other wildlife or take a dip in the refreshing pool just steps away. Whether you seek a relaxing getaway or a portal back to the days of our founding fathers, our historic home promises the ideal retreat.

Top guest favourite
A spacious exterior view of a two-story home features a blend of stone and stucco. Arched windows and doors create a welcoming entrance, while the surrounding area is landscaped with shrubs and trees. The driveway is paved, leading up to the inviting entrance.
Home in Hackettstown
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Charming Rustic Retreat

Discover timeless luxury wrapped in rustic charm. This home blends vintage character with upscale comfort, offering a warm, nostalgic atmosphere and refined touches throughout. From antique wood beams to handpicked vintage décor, every detail invites relaxation and emotional connection. Whether you're enjoying a serene morning or a cozy evening, this space promises a uniquely rich and elegant stay that feels like a heartfelt escape into classic sophistication.

Top guest favourite
A bright dining area features a wooden table surrounded by cushioned chairs, with place settings arranged thoughtfully. Large windows offer unobstructed views of the lake, filling the space with natural light and showcasing reflections on the water.
Home in Hopatcong
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Lakefront Hopatcong w/dock kayaks fishing near NYC

3800 sqt 4b 2.5b, stunning lakefront house on the largest lake in NJ. Breathtaking lake views from every room. Sunrise coffee at bedroom balcony. Grill in the sunset at the spacious patio, fishing off the private dock. two spacious living rm for multi family, well equipped kitchen, large washer dryer, 3 kayak, fishing rods, grill, everything you need for your group to have a comfortable lake retreat and make some beautiful memories. 1 hr to NYC.

Guest favourite
An inviting living room features a stone fireplace as a focal point, framed by large windows that allow natural light. A blue sofa is positioned beside a sleek glass coffee table, complemented by two orange armchairs. Warm wooden beams enhance the ceiling's charm.
Home in Jefferson
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 74 reviews

The Lakeside Villa

This beautifully refurbished home offers an authentic log-style living room with a dining area, kitchen, game room, 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The exterior living area includes a large gazebo overlooking the lake where you can relax around the fire pit, and two gas grills for outdoor cooking. Conveniently located right on Lake Hopatcong with easy access to marinas, nearby shops and picturesque mountainside hikes.

Guest favourite
A hot tub with softly illuminated water is shown in the foreground. Nearby, two glasses sit on a table, accompanied by a potted plant. An outdoor TV displays an aquatic scene, while warm lighting highlights the inviting setting.
Home in Hopatcong
4.84 out of 5 average rating, 79 reviews

Beautiful and Cozy, Lake view, hot tub, privt yard

Escape to this private 2-bedroom lakeside retreat, just 700 feet from Lake Hopatcong. Enjoy boating, fishing, kayaking, or a peaceful getaway in northern New Jersey. New York City is only about an hour away. After a day out, relax in the hot tub, gather by the fire table, or dine in the covered grilling area. With a large private garden and quiet neighborhood, it’s the perfect blend of comfort and convenience.

Top guest favourite
A miniature golf course is set against a scenic backdrop, featuring lush greenery and neatly arranged rocks. Vibrant red umbrellas provide shade for seating areas, while the lake and distant hills are visible. An American flag stands proudly along the water's edge.
Home in Hopatcong
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 90 reviews

Cozy House near Lake Hopatcong State park /beach

Very cozy house, well designed with unique style, located 0,3 miles away from Lake Hopatcong state park and beach(3min drive). Only 50 min away from NY. There is many activities around the lake including miniature gold overlooking lake, lake hopatcong cruises, hiking , restaurants with life music, boating activities (many marinas in the area offer boat rentals,paddle boarding etc).

Guest favourite
Bungalow in Jefferson
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 440 reviews

2 Queen Bedrooms

2 Bedroom cottage with Queen sized beds and a full sized sleeper sofa in the living room. This house works well for guests enjoying the many activities around the lake. We can fit an RV or boat trailer in our parking lot. Please check to make sure it is available before booking. Commuters enjoy the easy access to Rte 15 and I-80. **There is no lake access with this house**

Top guest favourite
The bedroom features a full-size bed dressed in a blue coverlet, complemented by wooden nightstands on either side. A large dresser and a bench are present, while natural light filters through two windows adorned with woven shades. A ceiling fan adds a touch of comfort.
Flat in Roxbury Township
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews

Clean, one BR apartment.

Enjoy our second floor, one bedroom apartment! (One flight of stairs - above our garage.) Perfect for one person but can accommodate two ( full-size bed). Our daily rate is $125 + a one time cleaning fee of $35. (All other costs are Airbnb & taxes)) Fully equipped kitchen. Fiber internet. We are located in Northwest NJ, just a few miles from Route 80 in Succasunna.

Popular amenities for Horseshoe Lake holiday rentals