Holiday rentals in Goodyear Lake

Tall Pines is a 4 bedroom cottage with lake access

A true lake experience! Located between Cooperstown (12miles downtown) and Oneonta (7miles to downtown) because of its central location, you can enjoy many local shops, family owned restaurants, many local breweries and on a bus route. Tall Pines Cottage has a cozy, bright atmosphere. Relax on the patio with fire pit & grill or enjoy the yard games. The lake access affords kayaking, swimming, and receive 20% off a guided fishing trip with Reels and Rods guide service. Kayaks available for use.

The Waterfall Casita: A-frame with 30ft Waterfall

Nestled among Hemlock trees & steps from a 30 ft waterfall is our cozy A-frame cabin. Sitting on 33 private acres connected to state land, enjoy waterfall views while sipping coffee in front of the fireplace. The casita was intentionally designed to feel like a home away from home. In summer, cool off in the waterfalls & private streams, in autumn take in the stunning foliage & in winter ski/snowboard at Belleayre (25 mins away). Alder Lake & the Pepacton Reservoir fishing are a 10 min drive.

Tiny glamping cabin with mineral spring hot tub

This off grid, alternative powered site is located towards the front of a large twelve acre estate, alongside a flowing brook. Elevated over a natural spring that flows year round, the Japanese inspired aesthetics of this private, tiny cabin sits perched atop a deck among the wooded trees overlooking the waterway the mineral spring feeds, but not before filling the in-ground, cedar lined, two person, bubbling hot tub heated with a wood burning stove. One of two glamping sites on the 12 acres.

The Lily Pad

The Lily Pad is a comfy one room king bed cottage with a porch overlooking the pond. A private full bath is close but not attached (attached to our home for plumbing purposes, but you have a private entry). The paved path is well lit. The cottage is insulated, heated,air conditioned, has electricity,Wi-Fi, and a smart tv used with your accounts. Fishing pole provided. The cottage is separated from our home by a garage. We leave guests uninterrupted unless they want to interact/need anything.

Romantic Cozy Cabin with a View of the Wetlands

Summer baseball renters please note: availability is Dreams Park tournament schedule ONLY -- not All Star! Perfect for a couple's getaway, a writing retreat, or a cozy home base to explore the area! Built in the 18th century, it now boasts an adorable fully-equipped kitchen, a charming wood interior, a vaulted ceiling, and a spacious deck with a view of the birdlife and wetlands. Swimming, hiking, and fishing on Goodyear Lake 5 mins away! Minutes from live music, cafes, and antique shops!

Lakeside Retreat

Welcome to Lakeside Retreat—a cozy cottage on Goodyear Lake offering stunning lake views and all the modern comforts you need for a relaxing stay. Just minutes from Cooperstown and Oneonta baseball camps, spend your days kayaking or canoeing along over nine miles of peaceful shoreline, fishing from your private dock, and soaking in the outdoor hot tub under the stars. In the evenings, unwind fireside with your favorite drink. The perfect blend of adventure and relaxation awaits you here.

Goodyear Lake Rental - Lakeside Baseball Getaway

Newly updated and furnished in 2024, Bluegill Cove features a private 100-foot lakefront beach with glacial pebbles, a firepit, dock, kayaks, & a giant float. Enjoy stunning lake views from the beach and nearly every room (see photos!). Outside, you’ll find two spacious porches overlooking the water, complete with a grill and dining for six. Ideal for groups of 5, the cottage includes a fully equipped kitchen and comforts of home. Located just 15 minutes from Cooperstown Dreams Park.

Modern House with Mountain View @Getawind

Experience luxury and comfort in our newly built property. Marvel at the breathtaking panoramic views of Rusk mountain through floor-to-ceiling windows. Unwind in the sauna or hot tub, and gather around the fire pit for cozy evenings. Enjoy outdoor movie nights with our projector, or savor grilled delights in the patio area. Warm up by the fireplace, explore Ski resorts, Golf Clubs and more. It's the perfect retreat for families and friends. Book now and create unforgettable memories!

The A-Frame at Harvest Moon Acres

Escape to this cozy, pet friendly Aframe tucked in the mountains - perfect for a peaceful getaway surrounded by nature with fireplace and mountain views in Stamford, NY, where the beauty of the Catskill Mountains surrounds you. Whether you’re sipping coffee by the fire, exploring nearby trails, or unwinding under the stars, the cabin is designed for comfort, relaxation and a little adventure Close to scenic hiking trails and nature spots. Short drive to local coffee shop and cafe.

The Mill House: An Enchanting Stream-Side Retreat

Nestled in the heart of the Catskills and just a 2.5-hour drive from NYC, escape to the perfect fall retreat where you can reconnect with nature and enjoy the serene beauty of the season. This historic gem underwent a recent restoration, marrying its saw mill heritage with contemporary luxuries, including a Nest thermostat, smart speakers, keyless entry, and fast wifi. Original exposed post and beam construction and Scandinavian-inspired design make for a unique and cozy atmosphere.

The Roost: Cozy Lakefront Vacation Getaway

Relax at The Roost - your private lakefront getaway on Goodyear Lake, in beautiful Upstate New York! This recently renovated 3 bedroom / 1 bath home has large yard & private lake access: perfect for bbq, swimming, fishing or kayaking (boats provided). Located 20 mins from Cooperstown, 15 mins from Cooperstown Dreams Park/ All Star Village & 10 miles from downtown Oneonta. A perfect place to stay for baseball campers, a getaway with friends, a family vacation or a romantic weekend!

Half Moon: Fairytale Catskills Retreat

Enjoy nature in style at this fairytale in the forest. This idyllic escape combines whimsical structures, curated gathering spaces and a private wooded hillside surrounded by hiking trails and quaint towns. Disclaimer: This is a rustic cabin. Heating is from a wood-burning stove, there is no AC. The bath house is a separate structure from the cabin, up a hillside with stone steps. Cooking is via charcoal grills, small outdoor kitchenette or fire.