Island holiday rentals in Central America

Find and book unique island rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated island rentals in Central America

Guests agree: these island rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

Island in Isla San Cristobal, Panama

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

Overwater cabin at Chocolate farm in Dolphin Bay

Looking for a quiet spot away from it all? Spot dolphins from your private balcony as soon as you wake up, go snorkeling, hike up the hill for amazing views, let the cacao forest enchant you or go paddling in a cayuco, a traditional wooden canoe made by the Ngöbe natives. Then pick a hammock, enjoy some of our chocolate & chillax like a sloth! At night, swim in the bioluminescent water, gaze at the countless stars or marvel at the sight of all the fireflies... Your next adventure begins here!

Superhost

Home in Long Caye, Belize

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Bad Kitty Beach House Blue Hole Long Caye

Welcome to Long Caye, an extremely secluded and unsoiled private island in the Lighthouse Atoll. Located 60 miles off the coast of Belize City, minutes from the Blue Hole & about 20 amazing dive sites in the largest living barrier reef system in the world. PLEASE NOTE: Boat transfer to & from island is $300 US per person round trip departing/returning on Wednesdays & Saturdays only. Private charter on other days of the week available at additional cost :-) Boat fees paid to captain direct.

Guest favourite

Guest house in Torio, Panama

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Torio guesthouse with panoramic view

Our private guesthouse is suspended over the Torio River, on the west coast of the Azuero Peninsula. It is a paradise for hikers, bird watchers, surfers and beach goers. Marked trails with posted maps begin at our place. Hike to a beautiful waterfall, mountain or beach. Photograph birds from the porch. Surf, body board and swim safely (no strong currents). Walk to good restaurants, and a small grocery. Experienced Surfers have Morrillo Beach and Playa Reina. Watch sun and moon rise.

Superhost

Island in Belize City, Belize

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Bird's Isle Cabanas

Bird's Isle Cabana serves the best of both worlds, being nestled on a small isle next to the Caribbean Sea yet only a stone's throw away from downtown Belize. It is furnished with modern comforts in a warm, cozy space. Choose to relax on the balcony whilst marveling at the sunset or visit nearby historical attractions such as St. John's Cathedral and the House of Culture. The island is home to Bird's Isle Restaurant, a popular spot serving up tasty Belizean dishes to both locals and visitors.

Guest favourite

Guest house in Utila, Honduras

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Sunshine Casita @ Sea-Esta

If you're looking for a peaceful and relaxing Caribbean getaway, consider renting one of our casitas. Our beautiful beach is surrounded by crystal-clear waters, making it the perfect destination for snorkeling, diving, and other water activities. The sunsets on Utila are absolutely stunning, and there's no better way to enjoy them than by lounging in a hammock with a cold drink in hand. Whether you're looking for adventure or simply want to unwind, our casitas on Utila are the perfect choice.

Guest favourite

Island in Placencia, Belize

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Hideaway Caye. Your Own Little Island!

You deserve an ADVENTURE! Belize Gold Standard accommodation. Have you ever dreamed of washing up on a deserted island? What if that island had an amazing cabin and a relaxing restaurant/bar to serve you? You can still catch your own lobster, fish and conch (whatever is in season). We at Hideaway Caye will clean and cook it for you while you lounge in a hammock enjoying a rum punch. We will make sure you always remember your experience. Brag to your friends that you rented a private island.

Superhost

Villa in Duncans bay, Jamaica

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 75 reviews

Sharkfin Villa, family beach house

Bring the whole family and enjoy this lovely, well-maintained home which boasts an open, free-flowing floor plan, with plenty of space for entertaining. The large kitchen overlooks the great room/dining room, ensuring you’re never far from your guests. This vacation home is equipped with your own personal cook who will blow your mind with the most fresh & delicious recipes the Caribbean has to offer. Footsteps from the famous Duncans Bay Beach; allowing you to enjoy the most amazing sunsets.

Guest favourite

Island in Belize City, Belize

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 59 reviews

Therapy Cabin 2 at St. George's Caye

This is a charming spot on historic St. George’s Caye. This beautiful island is where the country of Belize began. Just 30 minutes by boat from Belize City, airport pickup to and from the island is complimentary. Great fishing, swimming, kayaking, bird watching, biking and just enjoying nature! The property has 2 piers and 3 cabins. It’s a Green property! Solar Powered - each cabin has a solar water heater. Free Hi-speed WiFi even on the docks makes it perfect for “work from home”.

Guest favourite

Flat in Caye Caulker, Belize

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Sustainable, Eco friendly, Comfortably Numb

We offer a unique Eco-Chic, off grid experience to our guests that will be remembered for a lifetime. We are 100% dependent on solar energy and rain water catchment, and conservation is expected, but you’ll want for nothing. Located 10-15 min from town by bike, at the end of the golf cart path, close to the restaurants and bars but away from the crowds when you're ready to relax CURRENTLY THERE IS A CONSTRUCTION PROJECT 2LOTS OVER AND THERE WILL BE NOISE AFTER 8AM

Guest favourite

Hut in Cristóbal Island, Panama

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 123 reviews

Cocovivo Bioluminescent Coconut

Strategically placed to catch the sunset, this airy waterfront cabin is designed for ultimate relaxation. Perfect for sun bathing, sunset gazing and when night falls, strong bioluminescent waters makes this cabin seem like it's out of a fairy tale. A coral reef aligns the whole property for world-class snorkeling, kayak or SUP expeditions! Jetsons-meet-Flintstones" is the vibe here. Please read the “Other things to note” section so you know what to expect!

Superhost

Villa in Bocas del Toro, Panama

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Casita del Mar 'Over the water' Villa

We are proud to offer Casita del Mar, an eco aqua villa built over the Caribbean ocean in Dolphin Bay, on Isla Cristobal in the archipelago of Bocas del Toro, Panama. Situated along a mile long coral reef approx. 25 minutes by boat from Bocas town/airport and 2 hours from the Costa Rica border. The property has direct access to beautiful hiking trails and the villa is stocked with snorkel gear, paddleboards and kayaks for guests to use.

Superhost

Home in Tola, Nicaragua

4.62 out of 5 average rating, 78 reviews

Casa Guacalito - Ocean View Villa, Sleeps 8

[APRIL 2022 update] INTERNET ISSUES AT THIS HOUSE FINALLY RESOLVED! The internet is good for streaming multiple devices, video calls, netflix... all at the same time. Ocean view house 6 mins walk / 3 min drive to the beach. The direct path to the beach from the garden is no longer available. Large swimming pool, AC in bedrooms, well furnished terrace with ocean views. White sandy beach, great for swimming & snorkelling.